The paddle wheel aircraft carriers of Lake Michigan
98 points by surprisetalk 6 days ago | 9 comments

rkagerer 3 minutes ago
coal-powered horizontal paddle wheels

I guess "horizontal" here just refers to the shaft?

At first I was disappointed, as I had visions of an obscure drive mechanism where the wheel itself lies flat. Kind of like https://d36ndnmww3x0xq.cloudfront.net/trix-files/admin/pages... with interlocking gears that either suck water in through the front and spit it out the back via an internal channel... or alternatively external teeth that sweep out the sides of the ship.

Then some sleuthing led me to an 1840's prototype the Germ which really did have an underwater, horizontal paddlewheel: https://navalmarinearchive.com/research/docs/hunter_horizont...

(Drive unit shown above the ship, "A" denotes the waterline)

reply
stockresearcher 6 days ago
An awful lot of the WWII naval fighter planes you see in museums were pulled up from the bottom of Lake Michigan. The pilots training to land on these carriers missed fairly frequently.

The water at the bottom of the lake is great for preservation too, so the planes are usually in very good condition, except for whatever damage occurred when they hit the water.

reply
chasil 20 hours ago
I was aware of converted oil tankers ("oilers") that were fitted with a flight deck and hangar, but not paddlewheel propulsion.

I had a book from the ship's library of the U.S.S. Sanangamon, and I had read the wiki on the ship. (It suffered a grievous attack, but survived, and was scrapped after the war.)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Sangamon_(CVE-26)

reply
jordanb 20 hours ago
Sangamon was converted back into a tanker and wrecked ironically in Japan after the war.

The Sangamon class along with the Bogue, Casablanca and Commencement Bay were classes of escort carriers (CVE) created during WWII for anti-submarine operations. They were also used on a wide variety of tasks including resupply (especially of aircraft) to the front in the pacific war, and close air support of landing beaches.

The Sangamons (there were 5) were converted tankers; the smaller Bogues were converted freighters. The later classes were built as aircraft carriers. All together the US built well over 100 CVEs during the war. Several were lost.

USS Wolverine and USS Sable were converted lake steamers built specifically for training air crews. Of course the US needed vast numbers of qualified carrier pilots to man all these new carriers. Training pilots for carrier operations required an aircraft carrier. But at the beginning of the war the US was very short on carriers.

Additionally there were U-boats and Japanese I-Boats sinking shipping on both American coasts. Any carrier out there lazily sailing around while pilots practiced landings would be a sitting duck without a big fleet around it.

The Great Lakes were safe from U-boats but large ships couldn't yet enter them since the St Lawrence Seaway didn't yet exist, so they needed to use ships that were already on the lakes.

I believe George HW Bush qualified as a naval pilot on USS Wolverine.

The Chicago Maritime Museum is a very small but well-curated museum that includes a large scale model of USS Wolverine.

reply
chasil 20 hours ago
That's really informative.

The wiki doesn't discuss the reasons why the Sangamon was scrapped.

Thanks!

reply
Animats 24 hours ago
The U.S. Navy still has their main training facility near Chicago. And they still have weird training ships. USS Trayer is probably the strangest.[1]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQCh1mLTIGk

reply
trhway 14 hours ago
Speaking about mock-ups. A battleship in CA desert during WWII for bombing practice

https://www.facebook.com/groups/129145027099446/posts/283872...

Similarly, these days China built replicas of an US carrier and a destroyer in the desert for missile practice

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGQzlpu2I-I

reply
ashwinnair99 14 hours ago
The Navy requisitioned excursion boats to train pilots during WW2 and somehow this is not a more well known story.
reply
aaron695 17 hours ago
[dead]
reply
fsckboy 22 hours ago
TL;DR converted WWII pilot training ships when everything was in short supply
reply