Hacker News

40 points by andre9317 4 days ago | 26 comments

piker 3 hours ago

Honest question. Do people read these massive vibe-coded README.md files, or are they just artifacts?

The minute I see them, I tune out and move on. These types of docs come across to me as so over-specified and memorialized that I just find it not worth the effort to read. Of course for legacy projects this type of documentation would have been invaluable. What's changed, I wonder?

mulr00ney 3 hours ago

If vibey readmes are for LLMs like the other comments suggest, they should be banished to a folder where it's clear they're just for a robot so I don't have to look at them.

The README.md can actually be a reserved space for human beings to read with whatever the author thinks is most important to communicate to the human operator.

lukan 3 hours ago

Claude.md serves that purpose by standard and does not edit readme.md unless prompted so. I would keep it like that (or use another name for different agents).

Jabrov 3 hours ago

My eyes just glaze over when I see every file being listed and its purpose. Just because you CAN do that with LLMs doesn’t mean you should. What are you really trying to communicate?

flaminHotSpeedo 3 hours ago

I was under the impression the purpose of that is to give an LLM a cheap (in terms of context window) understanding of a repo, and not at all for the benefit of humans?

Whether that's effective is another matter, even if the LLM generating the list does so correctly and updates the list consistently

colechristensen 3 hours ago

Yes, that's for the computers to read. Maybe it's documentation that might be useful for a developer new to the project?

Zarathruster 3 hours ago

If we're fair, this is one of the better examples. It looked reasonably useful until it got to the 'CI / GitHub Actions' section. Many readmes take a very long time to describe anything useful, like how to get started or even what exactly the software is.

yesco 2 hours ago

Yeah I was expecting some giant text dump based on the complaints in the comments here, yet all I see is a pretty normal README? It's not even that large.

If we are splitting hairs some sections could have been left out or broken up into a dedicated doc, but this is still vastly better than a README that explains too little. At minimum I expect a README to give me guidance on what this is and how to get started with it and having stuff like a file layout helps with exactly that.

Thanemate 3 hours ago

We're in an era where the documentation is written to be read by LLM's, and I fully expect the README files to follow suit.

hootz 3 hours ago

README should be written for humans. Agents don't need fancy rendering in the repository page, we do. Agents already have their own dedicated context file.

dgrin91 3 hours ago

Isn't this the whole point of an AGENTS.md file? So that you can leave the readme for humans and put LLM-friendly crap in a separate file?

rvz 3 hours ago

If I see an excessively long README which is competing to being as long as War and Peace, I am immediately not going to read it.

This is just yet another low-effort slop specimen.

kylecazar 2 hours ago

Are we just saying this now for everything? The readme seems fine and is not long. The entire file is scannable in 1 minute.

schaefer 2 hours ago

It's 170 lines. that's not "massive".

iwontberude 3 hours ago

Yes, they are typically pretty useful for reproducing the setup. I argue also they are superior to most human made README.md because they explain what the project is at an abstract level, use more features of GitHub Markdown to communicate, and also generate diagrams which are helpful to visualize concepts.

fragmede 3 hours ago

You have. The words in the file still convey useful information, but because theres a particular writing style, you've deemed the words unimportant to read. If you went to a lecture about some topic you were interested in, but as soon as the speaker started talking, they sounded gay, and then you got up to leave because you just can't stand that, is that on you or them? Because the AI culture war of it's coming to take your job, so you'd better detect when something is made by AI, otherwise you can't enjoy it. Calling out every instance where AI is slightly off is a good thing to do. Because it'll be used to make the machines better at not doing that.

Coke Zero is good these days.

smarf 3 hours ago

its less the tone and more the oppressive volume of text

Catloafdev 3 hours ago

Why?

You keep posting this. What's it for? Who wants this? What does it accomplish?

It's a vibe-coded remote console renderer. I don't get why you're posting it.

jackb4040 2 hours ago

It's not only slop, it's low-effort slop. How does you post a link including "in the Browser", but actually running it requires some vague pointers about spinning up docker on a remote x86 linux machine?

serious_angel 3 hours ago

    But... why.... from all possible protocols and options out there for secure, and less complex channels out there... they chose the so featureful and pure overhead as SSH...  

    For low-latency VNC+Audio, why not WireGuard, WebRTC, QUIC etc.?

    Yes, Dungeon Crawl Stone Soup approached it relatively similarly for WebTiles, yet... it's infinitely different magnificent titles...  

    Oh... it's not them... it's Claude they used... or? Who knows, right? No one, including the priceless invaluable ideas of actual developers meat-ground into the Claude datasets now being sold for tokens...  

    // https://i.imgur.com/FM4aTMZ.png - SSH
    // https://i.imgur.com/9lZniqE.png - Claude

koolala 3 hours ago

Isn't it kind of just as easy to stream it from your desktop into your browser? Something like RustDesk doing remote desktop?

cyberpunk 3 hours ago

Geforce Now has had Dwarf Fortress for quite some time also...

Jabrov 3 hours ago

Sooo it’s just streaming a game to your browser. What does this have to do with Dwarf Fortress? There’s tons of generic solutions like this that would work the same way for DF as well. It’s giving AI slop.

mook 3 hours ago

This is the sort of trademark violation where I can get behind proper enforcement. It's using the name of an unrelated project for advertisement (attention).

perdomon 3 hours ago

Could this work with the actual game files (e.g. purchased from Itch.io instead of Steam) ?

andre9317 4 days ago

Play the classic (ASCII/2D) Linux build of Dwarf Fortress in a web browser. DF runs as a Docker container on a remote x86-64 Linux host at full native speed and is streamed to your browser over noVNC.