Windows 11 New Media Player Uses 3.5x More RAM, Charges for Popular Video Codecs
78 points by tcp_handshaker 4 hours ago | 36 comments

est31 2 hours ago
Removing HEVC support wasn't their choice but probably stems from the licensing pools increasing their prices [1].

Windows media player probably sees very little usage nowadays and probably even less for HEVC, when most content playback happens via streaming and browsers today.

As for the RAM increase, well that's probably a consequence of the general trend of doing frontend engineering via JS/TS instead of using OS native frontend APIs. The advantages are more on the development side of those apps, i.e. you can hire JS UI devs way more easily, and probably LLMs know way better how to deal with a react app than an UML one.

[1]: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2026/04/lawsuits-licensing-a...

reply
concinds 45 minutes ago
'It's worse for our users, but easier for our developers' is an unacceptable tradeoff, they deserve the backlash.
reply
cfiggers 39 minutes ago
I mean... Yes, but there's nuance here.

Using 400 MB of RAM vs 100 MB of RAM is close to unnoticeable in a world of a GB+ for a single Chrome tab... And if "easier for our developers" means the end user is getting more regular updates with fewer critical issues, then it's not an uncomplicated tradeoff at all, parts of it are actually synergistic.

reply
ruszki 25 minutes ago
There are 100s of processes running on my Windows without starting anything explicitly. They are using more than 10 gb of RAM. I am already feeling the consequences of this sloppiness. Especially that my IDE/compiler/emulator easily use 20+ GB. My 32 GB of memory is not enough somehow…
reply
sgarland 19 minutes ago
IME, there is a negative correlation “justifies increased memory consumption by citing DX” and “ships code with fewer critical issues.”
reply
SupLockDef 9 minutes ago
There is no nuance in 400%...
reply
srdjanr 5 minutes ago
Of course there is. If it increased from 1MB to 4MB, that would definitely be insignificant
reply
pdhborges 30 minutes ago
How come I have never seen this tradeoff work in practice?
reply
cf100clunk 2 hours ago
HEVC is provided by the official, licensed h265 standard. The open source ~HEVC-compliant codec library is x265 created by VideoLAN but was apparently not an option for Microsoft.
reply
cornstalks 58 minutes ago
x265 is an encoder, not a decoder. Also, being open source doesn't matter here: an open source library, even with a patent grant, doesn't give you a license to someone else's patents.
reply
ncallaway 41 minutes ago
> The advantages are more on the development side of those apps

I mean, I agree, but Microsoft of all companies really should be invested in building Windows native applications. If they can't be fucked to build Windows-native applications, why would anyone else?

Microsoft should be setting the example, and the high bar of what Windows-native quality software should be. It's frankly embarrassing for them that they can't or won't do it.

reply
pixelpoet 47 minutes ago
> The advantages are more on the development side of those apps, i.e. you can hire JS UI devs way more easily

Ah yes, we don't want Microsoft to run out of JavaScript developers to keep improving their desktop operating system in this manner. More webdevs, that's what's going to fix what ails Windows!

reply
winstonwinston 53 minutes ago
[dead]
reply
orthoxerox 39 minutes ago
I kinda have to hand it to Microsoft for dogfooding vibecoding with Copilot to such an extent. You can't say they encourage their customers to use a bad solution while doing something different in-house.
reply
y-c-o-m-b 44 minutes ago
I don't think I've ever voluntarily used their shitty media player since the classic version. MPC-BE (some folks use MPC-HC) is my goto with VLC as a backup if certain codecs don't play nice with it. I'm able to use nVidia super resolution with them as well.
reply
IronWolve 2 hours ago
Do people still use the K-Lite Codec Pack so their players have all the codecs installed? Or just use vlc?
reply
accrual 32 minutes ago
I loved the K-Lite Codec Pack and CCCP (Combined Community Codec Pack) back in the XP days, especially while exploring MKVs and anime, but I virtually never run into a media file that VLC or MPC-HC can't play by default these days. Just drop it in and it plays.
reply
megamike 4 hours ago
Is vlc still popular and widely used or is there a new 'kid' in town?
reply
magicalhippo 2 hours ago
Well there's an old kid in town, MPC-HC is still being maintained[1] to the great joy for us who dislike the VLC UX.

[1]: https://github.com/clsid2/mpc-hc/

reply
ReptileMan 3 minutes ago
Ugh... for the life of me I still can't understand why you can't click to play pause in VLC. Probably once upon a time it was about dvd, but the number of played dvds compared to pirated mk4 is probably one to a billion.
reply
functionmouse 4 hours ago
mpv is really good but a little light on the GUI; I recommend VLC for most people
reply
Mindless2112 2 hours ago
For media using common codecs, you could just drop it into Firefox.
reply
applfanboysbgon 2 hours ago
MPC is better if you're on Windows.
reply
AlienRobot 2 hours ago
PotPlayer is the new kid, I guess? Personally I don't like VLC because of the UI, so I've always used MPC.
reply
LollipopYakuza 15 minutes ago
Didn't they just publicly make an apology for enshitting Windows over the last years, and committed to go back to building native app?

I understand that project might have started way before the public statement but it really doesn't look good from a PR standpoint.

reply
shaokind 2 hours ago
What? I can find at least one article from 2018 about HEVC being pay-walled? [0]

EDIT: Also, what do they mean by "new" Media Player? It shipped in 2022 [1]. This article is garbage. The source article [2] is fine.

[0]: https://www.windowscentral.com/microsoft-now-charging-hevc-v...

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Media_Player_(2022)

[2]: https://www.windowslatest.com/2026/06/16/microsoft-reveals-w...

reply
ftchd 2 hours ago
So it started sucking almost a decade ago, checks out in my experience
reply
somat 45 minutes ago
Windows media player always sort of sucked. I remember when I discovered mplayer. What a breath of fresh air by comparison. ostensibly worse, with it's barely there user interface. But... all it did was play video, it would play anything, no more faffing about with installing codecs or different programs for different formats. No annoying ui that tried too hard to look like a piece of hi-fi gear.

I am not sure exactly what happened to it, it's maintainer moved on to other projects I imagine, it's current equivalent is probably mpv

reply
fuzzfactor 2 hours ago
The article mentions W11 24H2 but that might have been the only update the article had if it was first published much earlier. Might have even been an advance warning about AC-3 even before 24H2 was released.

Otherwise looks a bit deceptively like new findings just because the date at the top of the page says June 18, 2026 :\

reply
herf 2 hours ago
HEVC used to be a capped license per organization, so not providing it in the OS seems really harmful and expensive. Has the cap changed recently?
reply
queenkjuul 2 hours ago
HEVC has been a paid add-on for as long as windows 10 has been around, iirc.

Dropping AC3 does seem unnecessary.

reply
XzetaU8 2 hours ago
A solution for AC-3 is to get Dolby Digital Plus decoder for PC OEMs from here:

https://www.majorgeeks.com/files/details/dolby_ac_3ac_4_inst...

and then you recieve the latest update from windows store.

reply
lemonish97 2 hours ago
[flagged]
reply
functionmouse 4 hours ago
[flagged]
reply
epistasis 2 hours ago
The "power user" group which was traditionally completely Windows users is seeing some shifts to Linux. Linus Tech Tips' recent Linux switch tests went really well for Linux:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8KQFgWdiudo

Linux on the desktop is close, and Windows is getting a lot lot worse.

reply
rf15 2 hours ago
I switched to OpenSUSE this year. Good bye, Torment Nexus.
reply
MiracleRabbit 2 hours ago
Sadly you have to install the codecs from external sites.

This - at least for me - messes up the rolling release stuff at least one a month.

reply
close04 2 hours ago
I think Media Player is there just to have a built in option. Can’t say I’ve ever seen anyone use it, even non-techies install some other player in my experience.

The lack of codecs takes us back 20 years when everyone was installing codec packs. Both the Dolby and HEVC extensions now come from alternative codec packs. Not a real problem but does signal a degradation of the experience to the level that was usually considered the “downside” for Linux.

Always a good idea to run alternatives to every software that might pull the rug from under you. Always be ready to switch when the experience starts to stink.

reply
t1234s 2 hours ago
M$ knows the laws will change in their favor requiring a gov ID to boot a computer. This is how they will get away with crap like this.
reply