Internal Combustion Engine
162 points by StefanBatory 6 hours ago | 25 comments

londons_explore 31 minutes ago
Worth noting the design of the internal combustion engine hasn't changed much in 50 years.

The thing that has changed is the control systems.

What used to be a primitive mechanical way of mixing fuel and air (the carburettor), is now an electronic fuel injection system, with the fuel air ratio very carefully matched to reduce pollution (fun fact: modern cars release so little carbon monoxide, you won't kill yourself by starting one in a garage (but don't try it just incase your car is faulty)). Catalytic converters use any tiny fuel air imbalance to reduce carbon monoxide and soot, and on the other side nitrous oxides, by slightly increasing and decreasing fuel air ratios.

reply
bob1029 3 hours ago
> Presence of oil is critical here as it creates conditions for hydrodynamic lubrication.

You can hear this effect in some vehicles at initial startup time for a few seconds. I know of certain Ford engines where it actually causes issues over time. The model years with auto start/stop have the worst of the cam rattle disease.

reply
LeifCarrotson 16 minutes ago
Auto start/stop isn't off for enough time for the oil to drain from the galleries and especially not out of the bearing journals.

It's the first few seconds after an engine has been off for hours (or worse, for potentially years) that are the problem.

reply
Toutouxc 2 hours ago
Note that that sentence is talking about the crankshaft bearings and their hydrodynamic lubrication, which is, well, elsewhere and separate from any cam rattle issues (including the cam phaser oil starvation that you might be referring to).
reply
culopatin 46 minutes ago
Lifters also often drain while sitting and valve lash is greater at start until they get slapped a few times
reply
CraigJPerry 2 hours ago
The thing that's missing here that really drastically changes the story is all the emissions control hardware that would exist on such an engine.

This is a circa 1990s engine in the US market i think? Dual Overhead Cam didn't really become popular in the US market until then i think. 70s-80s for single overhead cam to become established.

The diagrams are beautiful and informative as always from this author.

reply
fauria 2 hours ago
"in real running engines the rotating crankshaft should float completely on a very thin surface of oil" - I found this to be a great insight.
reply
arlattimore 2 hours ago
The bearing surfaces in an engine (ex: crankshaft main bearings) have very tight tolerances, usually in the 15-25 thousandths of an inch. The engines oil pump fills those tiny gaps with pressurized oil which allow the metal surfaces to spin thousands of times per minute without damage.

This is also why if you have any issue with oil pressure (ex: oil pump failure, cracked oil line) or oil starvation (ex: driving a regular car on a race track, cornering forces slosh oil away from the oil pickup in the sump) issues, you'll damage your engine nearly immediately.

reply
LeifCarrotson 6 minutes ago
It's 0.0015, that's 1.5 to 2.5 thousandths, or 15-25 "tenths" as they're called.

That's not a particularly tiny gap in the machinist world, it's large so that you can pump viscous oil in it and deal with a wide variety of temperature changes.

25 thousandths would be sloppy, a nominal clearance hole for a 1/4x20 bolt is about that much.

reply
WalterBright 2 hours ago
That's the point of all uses of oil, other than rust prevention.
reply
calmbonsai 42 minutes ago
Some engines are also substantially cooled by oil, but those are either older designs (think “air-cooled” Porche) or industrial prime-movers.
reply
WalterBright 12 minutes ago
You are quite right, the oil also serves to transport the heat away.
reply
felooboolooomba 3 hours ago
Pro tip: Show a message if WebGL is disabled instead of a blank space.
reply
MarkusWandel 2 hours ago
Wonderful but it irritates me that so many descriptions of internal combustion engines refer to "explosions" of the fuel. You don't want that. It causes knocking and pinging and engine damage. You want a controlled burn that generates heat smoothly.
reply
Toutouxc 52 minutes ago
Not exactly. You do want a deflagration and not a detonation, but "explosion" is more loosely defined and, depending on who you're talking to, a self-sustaining subsonic flame front and a sharp pressure spike are a perfectly valid explosion.
reply
stouset 57 minutes ago
You don’t want detonation, but you do want deflagration.
reply
relaxing 56 minutes ago
Very interesting technology. Would be exciting to see a hardware startup build a product around this.
reply
bell-cot 6 hours ago
[2021] Originally 2333 points and 392 comments:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26991300

reply
mberning 2 hours ago
If you like this kind of stuff go and look up videos on the Rolls Royce Crecy engine from WWII. Absolutely insane engineering that died due the dawn of jet propulsion.
reply
mrhottakes 3 hours ago
Excellent animations.
reply
misiek08 3 hours ago
You meant - awful knocking combustion in the first, main animation? I never catches any real bug is those great posts, but this one, especially as first animation on the page - weird.
reply
Toutouxc 2 hours ago
You might be misreading the animation. It's a direct injection engine, the thing that happens during the compression stroke is fuel injection. Ignition happens a few degrees before TDC, which is realistic.
reply
lostlogin 2 hours ago
One of the rare situations where someone wants a bit of retard?
reply
zuzululu 3 hours ago
[flagged]
reply
throw567643u8 2 hours ago
Probably better for the environment too.
reply
rootusrootus 2 hours ago
No
reply