Medieval-style fortifications are back in the Sahel
14 points by andsoitis 5 days ago | 6 comments
0xcafefood 14 minutes ago
I thought walled towns died not due to state authority becoming stronger, but because offensive weaponry simply became effective enough to overcome walls. Walls can protect you from men with swords, but not from heavy artillery or bombers. Today, wouldn't a fleet of cheap drones render a wall moot?
replycineticdaffodil 11 minutes ago
Walls can not protect you from dhijadists either, the mortars take out the city- and besieging starves it out. In sudan- a "walled and ditched" city recently fell to the djandjhawid.. https://www.iss.europa.eu/publications/commentary/fall-el-fa...
replyreillyse 10 minutes ago
But they also protect you from more low level lawlessness and if the law situation inside and outside the wall are the same (because of stronger states) they stop being worth maintaining.
replyThink in the US, the cops wouldn’t survive against a couple of machine guns and a drone strike, but they are still useful for security purposes.
cineticdaffodil 13 minutes ago
A medieval culture that overproduces youth, allows for poly-gamy and is thus constantly stuck in wars and surrounded by a regional ring of fire wherever it spreads and encounters unbelievers reintroduces the medieval fortress wall wherever it goes? Just imagine if that had never been different for the last 1400 years.
replyhttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ribat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sand%C5%BEak
In the long run, i expect there to be anti-militant drone walls. Basically flying minefields in that region to become the standard against border incursions. If a culture can not produce peaceful regions, there will be a technological "security solution" that boils down to a automated drone driven dhijadi abortion system. Its not nice, but reality has to be dealt with and cheap.
A somewhat longer article of theirs is Why African Borderlands Keep Burning (April 15, 2026) - https://africanarguments.org/2026/04/why-african-borderlands...
and a recent paper Mapping the long-term trajectories of political violence in Africa (MARCH 2026) - https://arxiv.org/abs/2603.06502