Why Don't We Live in an Art Nouveau World?
27 points by shcallaway 2 days ago | 22 comments

BobBagwill 5 minutes ago
I think contemporary architecture is perfect:

Cheap, soulless, forgettable, replaceable metal and glass rectangular prisms filled with cheap, soulless, forgettable, replaceable workers. Form follows function!

That old architecture implied things like spirit, transcendence, community, beauty. Outmoded concepts for sure!

https://architizer.com/projects/tiktok/

reply
rad_val 11 minutes ago
I think the answer to this question is deeply uncomfortable in 2026.

Softly put, it's discipline, focus and a sense of greater purpose, far above the monetary value of things, fame and fortune.

In other words, exactly what our current, consumer-oriented society lacks. (for better or worse)

reply
vslira 11 minutes ago
I think the part of this post that is a push back at the “trad critique” doesn’t really work: at a point the author basically says that modernism has its hold due to being a (and I’m paraphrasing uncharitably here) cheap and easy shot at architectural respectability, which is not only not a defense of it, but pretty much the point of the “trad critique”
reply
fsloth 15 minutes ago
Not mentioned in the article - Helsinki has a large collection of Art Nouveau ("Jugend") buildings, though not quite matching Riga.

https://www.myhelsinki.fi/visit/helsinki-art-nouveau-archite...

"Helsinki is indeed a unique city of Art Nouveau architecture on the global scale, boasting no less than 600 “Jugend” buildings – more even than in Barcelona or Brussels."

reply
bondarchuk 42 minutes ago
Sort of a recap for normies of Scott Alexander's Whither Tartaria from 2021: https://www.astralcodexten.com/p/whither-tartaria

It is also interesting to read about the Amsterdamse School, an early 1900's style with "mass appeal" of which you can see many beautiful examples throughout the city, which were also only built thanks to strong support from the political sphere. https://architecture-history.org/schools/AMSTERDAM%20SCHOOL....

reply
Gravityloss 15 minutes ago
I went to Sagrada Familia and then to Mies van Der Rohe Pavilion.

The latter had a bikini fashion shoot ongoing.

Maybe something to do with it. The world and society completely transformed. Mass media, fashion, loss of religiosity, sexual liberation, globalization, social mobility...

reply
ctolsen 28 minutes ago
Sagrada Família is an amazing building. Going inside it is an awesome experience.

But it is a _lot_. Putting aside the artistic skill and construction cost of it, I'm glad I don't live in a city where everything is like that. I feel like it'd be overstimulating much like an analog version of the Las Vegas strip.

reply
loloquwowndueo 10 minutes ago
Did you visit other Gaudí buildings? La pedrera is open for visiting and a very nice apartment building. I wouldn’t mind a city where most buildings are like that.

Sagrada Família is very purposefully a total exaggeration but so are most large churches when viewed as part of their surrounding context. They’re designed to stand out.

reply
rad_val 20 minutes ago
The level of detail can vary while keeping the idea intact. You wouldn't be more overwhelmed than when you walk down on any european old city centers.
reply
Filligree 23 minutes ago
It’s no different from living in a beautiful natural landscape. I can tell you from experience that no, you get used to it.

It would not be a lot. It would fade into the background, except that any time you want to see beauty you just have to look up and focus.

reply
luqtas 16 minutes ago
nature has proven calming effects on humans... bird sings, even plants on the roof of an urban area can have positive effects just because of the vision

i highly doubt a christian church has the same effect. everytime i see a church i think about atrocities commited by the religion and alienation

reply
skinfaxi 14 minutes ago
> i highly doubt a christian church has the same effect. everytime i see a church i think about atrocities commited by the religion and alienation

Maybe not the exact same effect as nature but it is indeed calming to me at least. Stepping into a cathedral, or masjid, or temple and the noise of the world falls away (and I'm not even religious). I'm sure I'm not the only one.

reply
luqtas 5 minutes ago
i'm also not religious and having lived in a remote place for more than a year, i lost count of the amount of times i sat at the grass in a completely meditative state by starring at clouds, mountains and sunsets
reply
tocs3 9 minutes ago
everytime i see a church i think about atrocities commited

Not to downplay atrocities committed in the name of Christianity but I am pretty sure every large ideology has its share of of atrocities.

reply
skinfaxi 16 minutes ago
Compare Sagrada Familia to Times Square.
reply
rolisz 21 minutes ago
I'm lucky to live in an Art Nouveau City :) (Oradea, Romania)
reply
hommelix 11 minutes ago
Which area/building would you recommend to see Art Nouveau in Oradea?
reply
rolisz 9 minutes ago
Casa Darvas is a nice museum, with a good coffee shop in the garden.

The Central Square (Piata Unirii) has been renovated nicely and looks very good. The old main street is still in renovation, so it's not so nice now.

reply
toyg 10 minutes ago
One thing nobody ever mentions, probably because it's not fashionable, is that all these buildings require maintenance after getting built. Maintaining a modernist block, with its flat surfaces and straight lines, is utterly trivial compared to more decorative styles - where you have to constantly fight pigeons and the elements to not appear derelict. Also, it is typically complicated to fix decorative pieces when they break, as they often do.

I do understand and share the view that the current mainstream is utterly boring, but I also acknowledge the (somewhat) irresistible forces that shape it: money, time, effort. And I don't believe AI can do anything to counter them in a significant manner, sadly.

reply
hmokiguess 43 minutes ago
Unrelated but while scrolling, when I scrolled up, the asterisk thingy appeared on the top right corner and I thought it was a spider or some glitch and had a mini freakout before realizing it was the actual branding
reply
teddyh 27 minutes ago
Like those paper cutouts of lizards that people put on walls in order to fascinate cats.
reply
hmokiguess 20 minutes ago
Thank you for this idea, my cats are in for a treat today.
reply