The MacBook Pro's OLED PWM Problem: When a 'Better' Display Becomes Worse to Use
143 points by MacAnorak 3 hours ago | 74 comments

Velocifyer 27 minutes ago
I'm glad that this is bringing attention to flicker sensitivity.

Here are some other things that people are sensitive to: - CRI on white LEDs (and flourencents). CRI is how clean the spectrum is in comparison to the sun or a incandescent bulb, where the specturm is completely even.

- Motion blur Motion blur on LCDs (such as ~50% of Nintendo Switch 2s) can hurt eyes trying to keep track of what is going on.

reply
vitaflo 23 minutes ago
On the other end is motion stutter on OLEDs. Because of sample-and-hold, the blur goes away but the image stutters on slow moving scenes instead. If your eyes are sensitive to PWM (mine are) it's quite annoying to watch OLED movement as well.
reply
NathanielK 15 minutes ago
This os fairly fixable with post processing in your video player. For non video things, it goes away at higher framerates.
reply
vitaflo 6 minutes ago
Yes but then you introduce a soap opera effect. There's no silver bullet outside of BFI but that also causes flicker.
reply
legitronics 2 hours ago
When I actually went to the source for the 240hz claim, I didn’t reach the same conclusion as the testers?

Maybe they just let their rigol scope spit out 240hz, but 480hz worst case and I would actually say 960hz. I think what’s happening with the tandem oled is they both pwm at 480hz and 180 degrees out of phase giving effective 960hz when both are in use. Which appears to be most of the usable brightness.

Edit: I’m so confused.

“The PWM behavior is interesting, because we can see DC-dimming for all brightness levels. Usually, OLED panels use DC-Dimming only at higher brightness levels. The frequency is very low at 240 Hz, however, and this might be an issue for sensitive users, despite the DC-dimming. ” https://www.notebookcheck.net/Amazing-OLED-panel-Apple-MacBo...

reply
explosion-s 2 hours ago
As someone who’s had a concussion, this is really interesting. For me this is how any screen was to me, not just bright OLED ones. Even more interestingly it’s essentially only screens— backlist posters at the mall (paper with a backlight) still affect it but less so. To me perhaps it’s focusing on something on a screen that does this, but it’s really interesting to see this affect the general population.

It’s also odd to think about lack of ability to concentrate, and I wonder if screens cause this optically somehow but to a less noticeable degree even when less intense than this new one? (Independent distracting contents)

I noticed that adding a severe red filter to all my screens helped me significantly with the concussion and am also curious about that, would that impact the intensity of a refresh perhaps? Is blue light specifically the problem? I’m unsure but have a plethora of subjective experience.

I’m glad for this to enter public consciousness a bit and would love to see more research on the screen itself impacting our brain.

reply
Fnoord 29 minutes ago
After I had a psychosis (it was still 'active' at the time, in hindsight, but not as severe) I couldn't use a monitor for long, especially not gaming. It gave me immediate motion sickness, or made the headache more severe. Hw was TFT 1080p LCD screen, GPU was probably AMD 7770 HD, since a few years afterwards I replaced that with a Nvidia GeForce GTX 960.

My matte MBP 2010 didn't yield me this issue, but I didn't game on it either; just watched movies/series. A lot of them.

I grew up with CRT monitors though, and these could cause severe headaches. Especially if resolution too high.

reply
jareklupinski 34 minutes ago
curious; do you mean like a red plastic see-thru filter applied on top of the screen (filtering the backlight too, like those screen protectors), or a software screen effect that makes everything on screen appear red (which on an OLED screen would probably be the same thing)?

red/blue/green detectors (cones) in our eyes use different paths and have different "refresh rates" than luminous intensity sensors (rods), im wondering if filtering to a single color makes the rods take over for visual pattern processing

reply
achr2 2 hours ago
I am shocked that Apple would release a screen with such a low PWM frequency. Here is a paper showing humans can perceive flicker at frequencies more than double their display’s rate: https://www.nature.com/articles/srep07861
reply
jeremyjh 25 minutes ago
The change in that study was dramatically different: they had half the screen black and half white and were flipping which side was which at that rate. Yes, most people could perceive that. The study included 10 participants, all in their 20s. They didn't ask about headaches other observed effects afterward.
reply
kphorn 2 hours ago
If it’s as low as 240hz, anyone will see a stop motion effect by waving an open hand in front of the screen at 50% brightness.

I’m curious if this is a harmonic mode for a high speed PWM where pulses are either not even widths or the driver loses some power at the 240hz cycle. May perceive similarly.

I have a couple windows laptop workstations with high dpi OLEDs (one with 240hz refresh rate) that I love and don’t perceive this so I’ll have to check.

reply
avalys 41 minutes ago
I have one of these laptops, I tried waving my hand in front of the screen at 50% brightness and I don't observe anything unusual.

I think I am pretty insensitive to this effect, though. Other than occasional seeing a bit of 60 Hz flicker out of the corner of my eye from Christmas lights, automotive LED tail lights, etc. I don't tend to notice flicker.

reply
Telaneo 2 hours ago
I'd love for more research to be made into PWM sensitivity, if only to find out roughly how many people experience problems with it.

I've never had issues with it other than when trying to film certain old displays, but then again, I've never had issues with PAL TV sets running at 50 hz interlaced, nor even old PC CRTs running at 60, which definitely was not 'flicker-free', so I'm probably on the far end of the spectrum compared to the PWM sensitive.

It's an easy thing to forget, as with many accessibility features. And it's going to suck to have the nominally best display be one you just can't use if want to not feel like gouging your eyes out.

reply
rini17 2 hours ago
I do have issues with PWM everywhere myself while CRT was not big issue. I did tinker with refresh rates though. And I think difference is that

1. CRT display phosphors had afterglow.

2. the cathode ray was a dot moving across the screen, that might be easier on eyes than whole OLED screen flashing at once.

reply
vitaflo 13 minutes ago
I am sensitive to PWM, but not CRT's (I have an old Sony CRT I use to play retro games). The reason is that CRT's do not turn the entire screen on/off like PWM does, they draw scanlines. This isn't nearly as bad as what PWM does. It's the on/off of the entire screen rapidly that is the issue.

In fact there is research being done in the retro gaming scene of using CRT-like scanline drawing to mimic what CRT's do for modern displays. This allows "blackframe like" insertion without the flicker. Only issue is you need a very high refresh rate display to take advantage of it and there aren't many of those.

reply
ulrikrasmussen 2 hours ago
I notice PWM all around me all the time. Lots of cheaper LED lights use it, and I see it whenever I move my eyes, also when not consciously looking for it - instead of a blur I see series of lamps as a brief afterimage.

As a child I got headaches from CRT monitors at 60hz and I could see them flicker. I haven't noticed the PWM on modern monitors, but maybe these Apple ones would trigger me?

reply
dbspin 2 hours ago
I'd be fascinated to see how common this really is. Is it something that affects .0001% of users, more, less? At Apple scale an issue like that could hit millions of people. Given the newness and expense of the product one would assume not that many OLED Macbook Pros have shipped. So it's surprising that this issue didn't come up in testing if we're talking about more than a handful of people.
reply
Y-bar 2 hours ago
Given that we discovered in the nineties that CFL tubes were unhealthy for a significant portion of the population at these refresh rates and changed to over 30kHz I would assume the same holds true here. In other words: more than we would have thought.
reply
vitaflo 17 minutes ago
This has been an issue for all Apple OLED displays since they came out. I bought the iPhone Mini when it came out but couldn't stand it because of the PWM on the display. I had to get an SE instead which used an LCD display.

I'm one of the ones who is very sensitive to this. I get occular migraines often. It has become fairly difficult to find displays that don't have these problems as everyone moves to PWM dimming on everything. Even lightbulbs are a difficult purchase for the same reason (at least Ikea makes some that have zero flicker and are cheap).

reply
hartator 2 hours ago
I would say most people are actually sensitive, and report eye strain faster when using a specifc type of display, but don’t make the connection.
reply
microtonal 49 minutes ago
It's hard to put a number on it (e.g. do people with eyesight problems or headaches actually know it's their display?) and it may also be influenced by other factors. I have used phones with 240Hz PWM dimming for years and haven't had an issue. However, I quickly get eyestrain when looking at e.g. a Samsung S26 Ultra. It's probably the combination of 240Hz PWM, FRC for emulating 10-bit on an 8-bit panel, and maybe the two types of pixels (narrow and wide, for the privacy display) that makes it painful for me.

I can also imagine that lower frequency PWM dimming can be more problematic on a display that covers a larger portion of your sight. Many people also probably use their laptop/computer screen for a longer time without looking away (aside from phone addicts).

reply
spamizbad 29 minutes ago
It's likely to impact far more than .0001% of users. I'd put it closer to 12% - roughly the same percentage of the population that suffers from migraines. Granted, the degree of which it impacts the person will vary, but if these displays earn the reputation of triggering them, migraine sufferers will steer clear.
reply
Forgeties79 2 hours ago
.0001% is not nearly millions. They don’t sell billions of units
reply
tarsierscripter 2 hours ago
Even if they sold 100 billion units, .0001% would only be 100 thousand.
reply
Forgeties79 38 minutes ago
I decided to approximate because I didn’t feel like doing the rest of the math lol but yes even more ridiculous than I said.

I’m all about hyperbole, but that’s a bit ridiculous.

reply
incrudible 2 hours ago
PWM sensitivity has been an issue on the iPhone for a long time, but the prevailing wisdom is that it affects only a small percentage of users, and then only at certain lower brightness levels. Consider it like a food allergy, we don’t rearchitect the entire food supply for everyone around the sensitivities of a few.

That said, I have my doubts about prevailing wisdom being true here.

reply
brnt 39 minutes ago
A small aside: this is why I truly hate when people argue 'oh well, his only happens in 1% of cases, it's not worth supporting/solving'. With sufficient scale, and even without sufficient scale, it's thousands or even millions of people!
reply
snipem 2 hours ago
This is bad.

I had to return the Steam Deck OLED and LCD because their displays PWM was burning my eyes out. Sore eyes for days, having problems to focus properly. I hope this is a learning process and it will get better from the manufacturer side. But I hoped that after my personal Steam Deck fiasco as well.

reply
amluto 2 hours ago
I was expecting to read this and learn that the display was reasonably engineered and that there is some small subset of people who have extreme PWM sensitivity who have problems. But no, Apple modulates at 240Hz, according to plenty of articles.

We’re no longer in the dark ages of flicker. There’s actual industry guidance: IEEE 1789. And 240Hz, at any respectable depth of modulation, does not meet the low-risk limit, let alone the no-observable-effect limit.

I am wondering whether this is actually just an amazing firmware goof: the reports seem to suggest that operating at full brightness mitigates the problem, which makes little sense for an OLED display. An OLED showing 50% (post-gamma) gray ought to drive the pixels the same way as an OLED at 50% brightness showing white. And this display supports HDR, so even 100% brightness white isn’t really 100%.

I’m wondering if a little engineering mistake snuck in: some (most?) LCD displays dim by PWM-dimming the backlight, and plenty of backlights have current-to-light transfer functions that inherently low-pass filter the light. If someone naively ported the same logic to an OLED (which doesn’t have a backlight), they might have implemented brightness controls by applying a 240Hz envelope to the pixel excitation waveform. This makes no sense at all as an actual implementation, but I can totally see an AI doing it and writing tests to validate it :)

Even if there is a genuine engineering factor that requires low frequency PWM, I bet Apple could mostly mitigate the problem by deliberately mismatching the phases. For decades, pre-LED stadium lights had rather extreme flicker at 120Hz, but it was tolerable because the overall system was engineered to roughly evenly split the lights between three electrical phases, giving an effective modulation depth near zero.

I haven’t seen one of these displays myself. I find 120Hz flicker to be extremely obvious and very very unpleasant, and if these displays really do modulate in a nasty way at 240Hz, I expect I’ll be able to see it, albeit rather less obviously than at 120Hz. Also, pretty much any modern phone can see this in slo-mo video mode :)

reply
Exuma 18 minutes ago
Wait... so operating at 100% brightness mitigates this? I bought this mac and have been reading about this. Stare at computer 15+ hours a day coding, but I also never use anything less than 100% brightness.
reply
vitaflo 10 minutes ago
PWM is usually only used for dimming. So at 100% brightness there is no PWM being used. I'm not sure how this apple monitor works, but that's the basic gist for most screens that use PWM for dimming.
reply
formerly_proven 52 minutes ago
The "99% brightness has flicker" thing seems like a gaffe, but the general approach is common for low brightness levels.
reply
amluto 13 minutes ago
I did some digging, and apparently there are serious designs using this sort of hybrid dimming:

https://www.imec-int.com/en/articles/displays-health-patches...

Apparently brightness consistency between pixels is poor at low drive current, so designers often use a separate PWM envelope to compensate.

And there are even papers studying the choice of frequency, e.g.:

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41411543/

Unsurprisingly, 240Hz is not actually recommended (at least that’s what I get from the abstract, and I’m not about to pay to read the rest of it).

And, in an IMO pathetic example of how the US patent world works, there are apparently patents on obvious architectures like using a fast PWM clock and then discretizing the VRR frame interval to multiples of the PWM time. I thought of this myself about 15 seconds after contemplating that VRR was a complication and then I searched for it and immediately found two patents. WTF!

reply
sobiolite 2 hours ago
You're looking at it wrong.
reply
ThePowerOfFuet 48 minutes ago
I was going to downvote this, but instead I gotta say, what goes around comes around.
reply
evanjrowley 22 minutes ago
Looking forward to the price going down and perhaps a good refurbished deal.

The only use case I can think of for this machine is testing iOS touch interactions without a physical phone. Just this one specific purpose and it's not one that would require prolonged use.

reply
danbots 32 minutes ago
The shell is 1:1 to a mbp. I predict the following things will happen. Water damage- folks using their semi dry hands to touch the screen- that water is going to drip straight down to the logic board! Injury- those sharp corners at the top of the keyboard are just waiting for a power user to swipe. Screen separation. Touch screens were made with durability in mind- the hinge on the touchscreen mbp is identical in range to the stock mbp. Can’t wait till gen 2
reply
tasuki 53 minutes ago
The whole "OLED is better" narrative... for starters LCD has longer lifespan, no burn-in, no color degradation. I don't ever want an OLED in anything.
reply
vitaflo 8 minutes ago
Don't forget the OLED stutter on slow moving scenes because of sample-and-hold. It's why motion interpolation (soap opera effect) exists. I can't watch OLEDs because of it. Looks horrible.
reply
nixpulvis 44 minutes ago
I like my OLED watch. I like the high contrast... it's a small screen but I haven't noticed any degradation over like 4 years.
reply
rowanG077 29 minutes ago
LCD most certainly has color degradation. About 8 or 9 years ago I was able to compare a almost brand new surface pro 5 to my 3 year old one. I was shaken by the difference in difference.
reply
user982 48 minutes ago
I've 100% had LCD panels with burn-in, ghosting, and color degradation within the warranty period.
reply
wahlrus 50 minutes ago
Does anyone know if this is something that can be addressed in firmware or hardware?

For example, could we overlay a software dimmer while driving the panel at max brightness?

Or would it be possible to tune PWM settings from the OS?

Or would this be possible to tune with a firmware change?

Idk how these things work.

reply
incrudible 2 hours ago
I am not particularly sensitive, but switching the ipad pro for the oled model, I just don’t like the screen that much, and it is hard to put the finger on why. Side by side, the screen has better blacks and peak brightness and I am sure it beats the LCD empirically on many metrics. But I don’t like the colors as much, and perhaps subconsciously, the flicker is turning me off.
reply
LoganDark 2 hours ago
Seriously cannot believe the PWM frequency is 240Hz. I was shocked out of my mind when I first saw that. It needs to be on the order of kHz to avoid eyestrain for a very significant proportion of the population. Did Apple just forget about accessibility, or did they underestimate it?
reply
MYEUHD 2 hours ago
> Did Apple just forget about accessibility

To this day on macOS, the font size accessibility setting only works on first-party apps!

Even when using Apple's own UI frameworks, and using semantic font sizes that do actually scale up and down on iOS / iPadOS

It astonishes me!

reply
willis936 2 hours ago
PWM frequency is not selected in a vacuum. The maximum is set by your transition time which is set by a bunch of other engineering decisions. It's possible that something about tandem OLEDs make them more difficult to drive faster edges on.
reply
esperent 2 hours ago
Lenovo Yoga Pro 9i has a tandem OLED with 1200hz PWM.

https://www.notebookcheck.net/The-new-Tandem-OLED-panel-in-L...

reply
LoganDark 2 hours ago
Do slower pixels prevent you from using a higher PWM frequency? Wouldn't that make them like a capacitor smoothing out the high frequency signal into a constant one, like in a Class-D amplifier? That would reduce strobing even more!
reply
gniv 2 hours ago
Slight aside. I was thinking of buying a Google Pixel 11 but I learned that they have the same problem. I will go into a store and see if the Pro version (which can do 480 Hz) is OK.

Even if I'm not sensitive I am wary of this, what if it causes subtle eye strain that has long-term consequences?

reply
formerly_proven 2 hours ago
OLEDs commonly flicker at some small multiple of the refresh rate because they often use something somewhat similar to DLP bit-plane modulation to avoid non-linearity at low brightness. You can't do that at xy kHz because that would require xy kHz scanout to the panel, which is physically ... not very plausible. You can gate drive current, but then you're back to how a 2010 LED backlight operates.

This: https://www.notebookcheck.net/fileadmin/Notebooks/Apple/MacB... is perceptually very different from a low frequency low duty cycle PWM you'd get out of a cheap LCD backlight.

All OLED iPhones flicker below some brightness threshold, for example.

reply
api 2 hours ago
TIL there’s a pretty serious downside to OLED. Love the contrast ratios but not this.

I’m not super sensitive to flicker but can be annoyed by it. I’ve used OLED phones but it’s probably not as annoying on a small screen than one that covers more of your visual field.

reply
formerly_proven 2 hours ago
If you go in a dark room and set the brightness of an OLED phone to minimum and then just swing it around in front of your eyes you're very likely to see a stroboscopic effect. For iPhones this seems to become noticeable below about 20-30% brightness.
reply
katbyte 26 minutes ago
I guess I’m not sensitive to it as I did not have this happen. iPhone 16 pro.
reply
juleiie 2 hours ago
I Think Apple gets progressively worse and worse and I mean in a general way. There are some anomalies there and there but overall the direction is a slow decline in details and quality.

I love me some high end electronics that doesn’t feel cheap but soon it will be not worth it.

reply
LoganDark 2 hours ago
They have certainly been in decline ever since Jobs died. I really hope Ternus can flip it back around.
reply
juleiie 2 hours ago
It’s still many times cheaper to overhaul Apple than to start another company from scratch.

They still have the right ethos, philosophy and past traditions engraved in the History of the company. Someone just needs to remind them what are they supposed to be doing.

reply
KaiserPro 2 hours ago
Ok but who can actually see 240hz?

Like CRTs scan slower than that, and almost no-one could say they could see the pixels being drawn.

Sure you could hear those fuckers, but not see them, unless you had a source of vibration nearby.

Howe much of this is measurable, and how much of it is similar to the Himalayan salt lamp stuff?

reply
mrob 54 minutes ago
The problem isn't the flicker directly (240Hz is above the flicker fusion threshold), it's the phantom array effect when you move your eyes. Static images transform into a series of overlapping images, and this can be annoying and distracting. It's visible well into the kilohertz depending on how strong your saccadic masking is. I can personally see PWM up to about 10kHz (tested using a strobing LED).

AFAIK, all OLED displays have PWM flicker, and for this reason I stick with LCD, where flicker-free displays are available (although PWM flicker is present in some LCD displays too).

reply
rayiner 2 hours ago
I can easily see at least some PWM LED headlights flickering in my peripheral vision (which is more sensitive to flicker).
reply
Y-bar 2 hours ago
Fluorescent tubes used to run at less than 100 Hz before scientists discovered that that was unhealthy for many. Now they run at 30-60 kilohertz.
reply
LoganDark 2 hours ago
It's not about whether you can "see 240Hz". CRT phosphors have sustain, while OLED does not. The fully-on, fully-off cycle, if infrequent enough, causes some sort of visual stimulation that some brains absolutely do not like. You don't have to see it to feel it.

Sometimes I can tell flickery fixtures because they just "feel more staticky". I don't get visual eyestrain or nausea though.

reply
mrob 51 minutes ago
>CRT phosphors have sustain

Other than some old monochrome CRTs, all CRT phosphors decay too fast to prevent flicker. You get some softening of the trailing edges of the phantom array images, but they're not actually blurred together like on a sample-and-hold display. And even the fastest CRTs have fairly low refresh rates, making it more obvious.

reply
ZyanWu 2 hours ago
> You don't have to see it to feel it.

It's not magic. :) You DO see it. 500 Hz for the median observer; above 800 Hz for some individuals. https://doi.org/10.1038/srep07861

reply
LoganDark 52 minutes ago
This paper appears to be about the DLP effect that happens when a strobing light moves across your vision. Similar, but not the same thing!

There is still some ability to percieve strobing at a steady state though, even if the amplitude is reduced by visual persistence.

reply
kps 2 hours ago
Forget, no. Liquid glass? They've abandoned accessibility.

OLED plus dark mode is a way to juice advertised battery life.

reply
mono442 56 minutes ago
I also wonder how it will fare in terms of burn-in. OLEDs are infamously susceptible to burn-in.
reply
behnamoh 2 hours ago
This is one of the worst articles in terms of information per word density! Too many words and so much beating around the bush before it even discusses what the heck it's talking about.
reply
pxmpxm 51 minutes ago
Stopped reading after the first paragraph, straight AI slop aimed at SEO
reply
entrope 40 minutes ago
Hard agree. This in particular got me to stop reading the article:

> At 240Hz, the brightness fluctuation repeats 240 times per second; at 14,880Hz, it repeats almost 15,000 times per second.

Was that written for people who don't know what "Hz" means, or who don't know that 14880 is almost 15000?

reply
cnczeric 2 hours ago
[flagged]
reply
bob1029 2 hours ago
240hz is insanely low.

If you want to use PWM in an application like this you need to start at like 600hz. This is how fast the subfield drive on a plasma TV is.

I have to use incandescent lightbulbs for certain fixtures because I sometimes need a break from engineers who think they are smarter than me.

reply
gowthamgts12 2 hours ago
In my experience, Apple hardware always gets better over time. So, you should never buy the first hardware "innovation" changes that they do.
reply
solyin 2 hours ago
On the other hand, the first version is always the most hackable.
reply
intrasight 2 hours ago
> But some people are particularly sensitive to this kind of modulation and can experience eye strain, headaches and other forms of discomfort when looking at displays that use it.

So that tiny fraction of users would be well served with some other display and can either return their MacBook or use an external monitor if and when they find out that they're in that cohort.

reply