Many of Amazon’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday “Deals” Offered No Savings
442 points by DeepLogin 4 hours ago | 249 comments

ilamont 2 hours ago
The best thing I did wrt Amazon is kill off my Prime account. It eliminates hundreds of even thousands of dollars of wasteful impulse purchases every year.

Most online retailers (Amazon included) still give free shipping above a certain threshold ($35 per order or whatever) so for things I need, I wait until I reach that threshold to place the order, and often purchase at other retailers or directly from the brand.

Also, everyone does "Black Friday" sales nowadays, in many cases matching the same window as Amazon.

reply
alpineman 2 hours ago
Amazon is just such an inferior shopping experience these days. Full of ads, horrible, dated UI. Fake reviews. Even then you often don't know if the product you'll get is authentic.

Since I stopped using Amazon I realised most websites now have a super easy purchase flow with Apple Pay or Stripe and the convenience factor just isn't a big difference any more. I also most of the time pay less than Amazon.

reply
randycupertino 2 hours ago
I've noticed that amazon-owned audible has deteriorated to an almost hostile user experience as well. They make it super hard to search your own book library and instead push you over to the for-sale library so you accidentally buy a different version of a book you already own. They also took away the ability to sort by price from low to high because people were using it to search and buy on-sale books. Customers revolted and they put the sorting button back. They also don't have an ability to easily remove things from your wish list or any way to easily filter out AI-narrated books.

Overall it's frustrating and feels like it's intentionally designed to trick you into buying things you don't want.

reply
tyfon 52 minutes ago
You buy on audible, download with libation and index/serve it with audiobookshelf.

So much better than the app and nobody can take away or change the content :)

reply
shimman 44 minutes ago
Never heard of libation, thanks for the suggestion. Exactly what I needed too!
reply
threecheese 2 hours ago
They also limit the sale-price usage; if you buy several sale price audiobooks, they jump the price back up. Last I tried I got three, the fourth allowed me to submit but 500'd (dog page) and then the price jumped back up.
reply
nalekberov 32 minutes ago
Arguably Audible and Kindle are best products under Amazon umbrella.
reply
hombre_fatal 18 minutes ago
I left Audible when I cancelled my membership, intending to resume it later, and lost ten months of credits since I couldn't keep up with spending them.

Oh yeah, and they had multiple false-positive screens where you think it's a "Successfully cancelled membership" screen where you can close the tab, but they're actually more like "Successfully got to this screen where you must click Confirm again".

They have a lame, pointlessly limited "pause membership" system you're supposed to use instead, but it's less insulting to just cancel forever.

reply
thefourthchime 10 minutes ago
I've tried to quit Amazon, but there's no good alternatives. Walmart+ is the best that I've found. But unless you're buying things that they actually sell at the retail stores, you're getting the same sort of Chinese drop ship crap with fake reviews. But with worse shipping.
reply
BeFlatXIII 27 minutes ago
If it were a real dated UI that consistently worked, it'd be a better UX. Instead, it's somewhat janky and inconsistent UI.
reply
busymom0 29 minutes ago
Amazon is the only place you can buy reputable brands like JMVIERZ, TANDZVXR, BOOJO, MLYENX...
reply
nalekberov 28 minutes ago
Don’t forget Abibas.
reply
furytrader 16 minutes ago
And Coofandy!
reply
_doctor_love 13 minutes ago
Dont forget Air Hordans for the kids
reply
stronglikedan 2 hours ago
To each their own. I don't impulse buy anything, but when I do want something, I want it now. Amazon is the only service that can provide that for the vast majority of products, with Walmart filling in the gaps for the rest (but not as fast as Amazon). Literally no other vendor can compete with those two on shipping speed without paying a huge premium.
reply
MSFT_Edging 2 hours ago
> when I do want something, I want it now.

God I miss being able to walk into a store to find a quality item that I need. Nowadays it's really only Microcenter where you can decide "I need this thing" and come home with that thing.

At some point, we lost the plot on online shopping. Sometimes physically going to the store to hold an item in your hand and bring it home within the hour is far more convenient than comparing 4-8 items online and waiting several days for it to arrive.

We really lost a lot when almost all shopping went online.

reply
wiether 2 hours ago
Idk...

Without ecommerce I'll be running a shitty Asus or whatever consumer laptop they sell in stores.

I'll still have to buy a new headset every six months because they only sell garbage products.

I'll still have to buy a new blender every year because they only sell the low-power ones.

I live in a big city so there is some niche stores were I can go and get actual quality products, but the big stores are all selling the same trash they were selling when I was a kid, and I don't see the point of going there when I can buy quality products on niche websites.

reply
SoftTalker 36 minutes ago
This just isn't true. You can order direct from the Dell or Apple store. Or another consumer electronics seller such as B&H (who have been in business since the mail-order days). We've had mail-order shopping for centuries, which always offered more choice than local retailers. You can get anything you want. Ecommerce just moved the catalog, ordering, and payment off of paper and post to electronic. It's fundamentally the same otherwise.
reply
MSFT_Edging 33 minutes ago
There were catalogues and mail-order prior to ecommerce. That's what makes Sears' downfall so crazy. They had the infrastructure, they just had to digitize.

Back in the day, you'd buy a computer magazine and find reviews for the computers, and there'd be ads for the computers with a phone number and address. You could request a full catalogue, and get the niche thing ordered.

reply
sylens 53 minutes ago
Yeah, this is the biggest obstacle in getting me off Amazon. I am very much up for going to a store and buying the item instead of waiting for it to be delivered. But so many stores do not carry sufficient inventory anymore. I've also found that Microcenter is the only one that feels like going to a store during the 90s
reply
MSFT_Edging 37 minutes ago
Microcenter filled the nostalgia hole of what Toys R Us was to me as a kid.

Even though it's all just blatant consumerism, I genuinely think kids today lost something cool when they could no longer convince their parents to take them to the mega toy store, filled floor to ceiling with cool stuff.

Even though it was corporate magic, it was still magical to have a place like that. Now it's just all ipads.

reply
jerlam 58 minutes ago
I just ordered from Walmart for the first time in years, and was pleasantly surprised to get same day delivery (not just shipping) for free, no membership or anything. The only thing Amazon would do on the same day is send me an email telling me that I could add items for free to my order, and the items would arrive after seven days.

These were items that would undoubtedly be behind the locked counters at Walmart, where it would take some time to get a worker to retrieve the items. But at least they would be directly from Walmart's supply chain, with no chance of getting fakes co-mingled in Amazon's warehouse.

Amazon is nowhere as good or special as they used to be.

reply
MSFT_Edging 46 minutes ago
I feel like walmart is trying very hard to follow Amazon's footsteps. From what I understand a majority of the online stuff is set up similar to amazon, along with various third party vendors.

There will probably come a day where the walmart online shopping is just a blue and yellow version of amazon with few benefits.

reply
SoftTalker 43 minutes ago
There are many third parties selling on walmart.com.

If you want same-day delivery you are limited to what is in stock at the nearest local store. And even then, sometimes they will only offer in-store pickup, it may depend on how backed up their delivery is (they use gig workers).

Set your search filters to "sold by walmart" to eliminate the third party stuff.

reply
jerlam 32 minutes ago
Yes, but it's the same as Amazon. People are continually warned to only buy products that are both shipped and sold by Amazon, both for free shipping and for the authenticity of items.
reply
mindslight 6 minutes ago
[delayed]
reply
delecti 19 minutes ago
Note that Amazon stopped that co-mingling in their warehouses earlier this year. I don't know what effect it's had on their counterfeit problem, if any, but it's at least one risk factor mitigated.
reply
esseph 13 minutes ago
> Amazon is nowhere as good or special as they used to be.

As of two days ago, I am now able to get "Free overnight delivery" on many items with delivery windows from 3am-5am or 5am-8am. That's pretty awesome.

They're also testing drone delivery nearby.

reply
rockostrich 2 hours ago
Harbor Freight as well. If you need a tool, then they probably have it in stock. I'll gladly pay the $30/year for a membership because I end up saving that much with the members discounts anyway and I end up getting something like 5-6 free buckets or packs of microfiber towels every year. And if there's anything I always need more of it's buckets and towels.
reply
swasheck 29 minutes ago
I do love Harbor Freight but I've found the cost savings is offset by the quality so I end up rebuying quite a few things things that break after a few strenuous uses (I've bought more than a few sets of Pittsburgh Obstruction Wrench sets) but it does seem to meet the budget needs "right now."
reply
mindslight 28 minutes ago
I'm currently an ITC member, but I wouldn't tout it as some unequivocal benefit. The delta on most of their sales is an additional 5% or a few days of early access. It's good if you're building up on tools, or obviously if there is something you need right now that is on ITC for less than the cost of the membership.

Also one major thing I feel that is missing from all of these discussions every time "Amazon" comes up is that different types of stores have different value propositions. IMO for the bulk of their products, HF's is that you're paying a bit extra (even after sales/coupons/etc game) for more predictable quality compared to hit-or-miss GENSYM brands on Amazon/eBay/AliExpress.

reply
robby_w_g 2 hours ago
The “quality item” is the important part to me. I don’t care about getting something in 2 days instead of 4-5. I care more about the item I’m buying being good at its function and lasting longer than a year.

In regards to the physical location, I recently purchased a sectional online. The store had a showroom at the mall, so we could test the comfort of the couch and its various add-ons. We ended up going with that store vs comparable online options because we actually understood what we were getting.

The only disappointing part of the process was that there is no incentive to purchase the couch from the physical location. I was looking to get a commission for the store while also maybe scoring a free add-on, but the employee said there was no point because they don’t get commission and they don’t give out add-ons. It’s a bummer because I want to reward the location for its help and keep it running, but it was a worse experience to do so.

reply
SoftTalker 34 minutes ago
Did you try giving the employee cash and saying "put that in your pocket."
reply
hirako2000 2 hours ago
We lost a certain convenience and the ability to check first hand before buying.

But I remember back then it wasn't unusual to see a retail price sticker at $59 the shop, to find the exact same thing on Amazon for $19.90.

We figure staff walking around doing nothing need paid, prime real estate isn't cheap, even when the shop is empty.

reply
saxonww 31 minutes ago
I would say the experience of "I can get whatever I want, today" has always been rare. It's still disappointing that people who used to have it don't anymore.

When I was growing up you might have a nearby mall with e.g. Babbages or similar, and there were a handful of other stores that might have stuff you wanted (Radio Shack, Service Merchandise, Toys-R-Us actually had computer equipment for a little while; I've never seen a Microcenter or a Fry's), but you were still limited to whatever they had locally. If you wanted something else you ordered it from their catalog and you could pick it up later. The catalog was always bigger than the local stock.

reply
techpression 59 minutes ago
Still go to the local camera store, good banter, sometimes a friendly deal, a good experience all in all.

The problem in Sweden where I am is that it's close to impossible to find certain type of items, and Amazon has thousands available for next day delivery. Also things like German products, which are often very good, is easily accessible, while the Swedish stores all carry the exact same inventory more or less.

reply
MSFT_Edging 44 minutes ago
I went to a local camera shop recently for work. The banter was great, tons of used stock. All quite expensive but the customer service and ability to get there in 15 minutes made up for it.
reply
sethhochberg 8 minutes ago
I genuinely wonder how much of their sales come from people, essentially, trying to bulk up an order so they don't feel bad about a delivery.

Just a couple of weeks ago I found myself in somewhat urgent need of a small number of 4-pin Phoenix terminal block connectors to finish a project that I really didn't want to roll over into another weekend. Amazon sellers had them and could get them to me next-day and while I probably could get them somewhere like Microcenter, the nearest Microcenter is almost an hour away. Even here in NYC it can be challenging to find stuff like this locally.

But I feel _terrible_ placing such a small order, so it turned into an exercise of throwing soap, vacuum bags, and a few other consumable household things that I know I'll need more of anyways into the cart just to make the delivery worth it.

reply
OvervCW 2 hours ago
This must be specifically the experience in a market as big as the continental US, because here in the Netherlands (a rather small country), both Amazon and random-cheap-raspberrypi-shop.nl deliver your package tomorrow.

In fact, in my experience the latter is less likely to randomly delay a package by one day.

Both of them allow you to pay using the same online banking site that's as easy to use as Google/Apple Pay, with the random local store also allowing you to send the package to a pickup point in case you know you aren't at home. Amazon pretends to offer this option as well, but in practice the website constantly throws weird errors at you about the pickup point being full or unavailable.

In short, the shopping experience at Amazon is much less user friendly than any random online store you can find here, and I only end up buying there if I need Chinesium that's not for sale anywhere else.

Weirdly, even more well known brands like Belkin, seem to offer some of their products only through Amazon and it's impossible to buy them anywhere else, meaning that I often have to use Amazon against my will.

reply
zdragnar 50 minutes ago
NL is, as you note, a tiny and very densely populated country.

For comparison, the nearest UPS distribution center from me is a 40 minute drive at highway speeds. Fedex is similar. The nearest USPS post office is only 10ish minutes at mixed speeds, but they have to receive something from one of their own distribution centers first, so same day isn't happening.

It's possible to get same day shipping from exactly one local store, and that's only for items they have in stock on the shelves that I could just go pick up myself. Next day shipping isn't available from anyone but a few big box stores, again for items they have on shelves, because the population density is low enough they don't send out trucks for just the one delivery.

OTOH, there's a lot of items on Amazon that are consistently two day deliveries (especially with Prime), because enough people are buying that they have at least one, if not more, deliveries from their distribution center to our post office every single day. It can get as high as 3 or 4 semi trucks dropping off packages at our post office during the holidays.

Edit: it's worth pointing out that I'm considered in an area that is only borderline rural, with my town having a density of roughly 90 people per square mile (34 per sq km). There's counties in my state with a population density of less than 1.

reply
svachalek 29 minutes ago
The US comparison would be more like your cheap raspberry pi was in Greece, how long would it take then?
reply
njovin 56 minutes ago
Not judging your decisions, but this reminds me of a sentiment I saw somewhere a long time ago that stuck with me:

"I can order a toothbrush from Amazon and start a chain of human suffering several hundred miles away".

reply
jimmydddd 35 minutes ago
I have five friends who work for Amazon at different locations, two in warehouses (but as supervisors, not pickers), and they all say it's OK to work there.
reply
jimmydddd 38 minutes ago
And the no-questions-asked, no shipping costs, no box needed returns are amazing. I had to return an item of clothing from the online store of a clothing store, and the process was crazy. The Web site said I could return to the brick and mortar store, but when i went to the store, they said I could not. Then I had to provide packaging and pay for shipping for the return. Stuff like this used to be normal, but it seems crazy after you're used to Amazon.
reply
mbesto 39 minutes ago
And returns. I understand reverse logistics is super hard to do when you're not at scale, but next day shipping and easy returns to my local UPS are what keep me on Amazon.
reply
danesparza 26 minutes ago
"I don't impulse buy anything, but when I do want something, I want it now"

This is literally in the definition of "impulse buying" (the desire for instant gratification). I'm not sure why you need to qualify it incorrectly.

reply
Fargren 9 minutes ago
It's not. "Impulse buying" is when you get an impulse to buy something and buy it without considering if you really need it, or if you might be better with a different alternative or without the product. It's about the time between wanting and paying, not the time between paying and receiving. Many people impulse bought a GTA preorder and waited years to receive it.
reply
roughly 50 minutes ago
> when I do want something, I want it now

What’s fun about this is time is the absolute most expensive thing you can buy, and that’s been the case for all of human history. Empires have been built on the back of rich people’s willingness to throw away fortunes to not have to wait a couple days to get their desires filled. It’s a pricy way to live.

reply
SoftTalker 45 minutes ago
Where I am, Amazon is no faster than anyone else. I can get Walmart same-day for some things, Amazon is at least overnight and usually 48 hours or more. I've waited weeks for some things (depends on the seller), which is no better than mail-order catalogs were doing in the 1970s.
reply
legitster 48 minutes ago
Also, the return process for Amazon is still the industry high-water mark.
reply
MSFT_Edging 42 minutes ago
I still prefer getting in my car with the receipt and item and getting my money back.

Online returns are rife with nonsense. I still need to print out a receipt and take it to my local wholefoods anyway.

reply
swasheck 26 minutes ago
> Online returns are rife with nonsense. I still need to print out a receipt and take it to my local wholefoods anyway.

Interesting. The normal workflow they present to me is that I initiate a return, I get a QR code that I take, with the item, to Whole Foods or UPS and they scan it on my phone and everything "just works."

reply
krzyk 22 minutes ago
Strange.

In my case it is most times: "Click I want to return. Select how I want to return", go to parcel box (which I have ~150 meters from my house) and send it. It is exactly the same process when I order, but reversed (I receive 90% of my parcels at the parcel box, you know the automated one)

reply
danesparza 21 minutes ago
Apparently you are not familiar with Costco.
reply
webdood90 48 minutes ago
I'm convinced that a major contributor to the degradation of society is from the prioritization of convenience above all else.
reply
MSFT_Edging 41 minutes ago
We want our cheap plastic crap to temporarily enrich our little lives and we want it NOW(2-3 days).
reply
td521534f12 2 hours ago
I don't have prime and half the time when I buy something on Amazon it arrives in two days anyway.
reply
logifail 48 minutes ago
> I don't impulse buy anything, but when I do want something, I want it now.

I recently bought a baseball set for one of our kids. I wasn't convinced about any of the sets on Amazon, so picked what I thought was a better alternative, an actual sports retailer which had an online shop. I had to pay for shipping, but I figured it might be worth it.

Ordered around lunchtime on a Tuesday, think they shipped it Thursday, it arrived Monday. Is it just me, or is this fairly meh service?

reply
SoftTalker 26 minutes ago
Seems OK to me. You had a non-essential item in less than a week without doing any driving. Far more important to me would be if the set turned out to be any good. Many "big name" sports retailers sell some pretty garbage equipment.
reply
arealaccount 2 hours ago
Two day shipping that arrives three days later
reply
nalekberov 34 minutes ago
Most people do, and Amazon exploits this vulnerability at every chance. The biggest lie billionaires want us to believe is “Humans are rational”.

This is why they offer (at least in my case) free trials (worst case scenario: 3 months for 0,99€) year long.

reply
swed420 9 minutes ago
> so for things I need, I wait until I reach that threshold to place the order

I find waiting a bit also helps me avoid buying things I ended up not needing thanks to finding a workaround, etc.

reply
guerrilla 2 hours ago
> Also, everyone does "Black Friday" sales nowadays, in many cases matching the same window as Amazon.

Black Friday predates Amazon by decades, by the way.

reply
ilamont 2 hours ago
Indeed.

But Amazon has gradually expanded the definition of what Black Friday means ... first with "Cyber Monday" ("BFCM") and then to a huge chunk of the month of November.

Last year, it was 10 days long.

reply
KerryJones 24 minutes ago
This isn't just Amazon? Do you have evidence that Amazon started this trend? I remember in 2013 when stores (like H&M) were expanding it to the preceding Wednesday
reply
delecti 6 minutes ago
Yep. And for a few days already, they've been offering the ability to "shop early deals". So they've exceeded 2 full weeks of BFCM deals, which ostensibly should be at most 4 days long.
reply
arealaccount 2 hours ago
I’ve had the same experience. Cancelled just because I didn’t want to pay the fee, then one day realized the tiny speed bump of having to go to a store reduced my impulse spending by almost 600%
reply
mportela 2 hours ago
It is kind of applying all of the research Amazon has been sharing for the past decades against Amazon itself: every added millisecond of friction reduces consumption by a lot.
reply
jdc0589 2 hours ago
im curious what kind of impulse purchasing most people are doing on amazon. Im not questioning it, im just so deep in to my own specific kind of impulse purchasing i dont even know what kind of random crap people are buying on average.

for me, its almost completely: tools that will make something slightly easier or are so much cheaper (e.g. large SDS+ core drill bits), misc cheap hardware/parts that are too specific to reliably find at Lowes/HD/etc...

reply
GenerocUsername 2 hours ago
I know HN isn't the place for this, but I know from personal experience, friends, and sitcoms,that WIVES place absurd numbers of purchases nearly daily. I'm talking 1-5 individual purchases on many days.

Nick nacks. Shirts. Household supplies (that's fine), anyway at my house about 1/10 purchases are generated by me. And many of my male friends commiserate to similar. Plus I see the trucks... And stacks of boxes at neighbors doors so I know it's similar even outside my domain of personal knowledge.

reply
dpark 28 minutes ago
> sitcoms

Sitcoms also consistently show that men are fully incompetent so maybe don’t try to cite them as evidence of anything in the real world.

> WIVES

I don’t know. I see lots of guys who buy lots of crap. Anecdotally I also see men buy more expensive things even if the count of things is smaller. “I definitely need to purchase this high end tool for this small task.”

reply
ilamont 2 hours ago
In my case, it was often start with things that would otherwise require a trip to the home improvement center or the supermarket, like a can of wasp spray or a box of coffee filters. While you're on the site, you might see something else you didn't really need but just add it to the cart.

If you have family members on the plan, all kinds of other things get ordered.

The next thing you know, Amazon deliveries are coming two or three times per week, and you realize you have a problem.

reply
Hobadee 2 hours ago
My wife buys stuff for our kids all the time... Clothes, household goods, books, etc...
reply
apercu 29 minutes ago
I kept mine for a little while after I stopped buying things from Amazon but when they added ads to everything on prime it was an easy budget casualty.
reply
yathern 2 hours ago
I recently noticed the same thing in a more specific Niche - 11.11 sales for Mini PCs on AliExpress.

Not just jacking up prices and having fake sale prices (they do that year round) - but a specific pattern to throw off naive URL or SKU based price trackers:

They delist old models, and add them back in, sometimes with different model names, but the same specs. The week before the big sale, there were hundreds of delistings, and the average price rose nearly $80 - so that the $50 off becomes an increase.

https://minipcs.zip/aliexpress-11-11-pricing-tricks/

I've been tracking Mini PC prices on Amazon for months now and am excited to see if the same pattern repeats for Black Friday. (There's other weird patterns on Amazon, such as listing the same PC 10 times with different prices, all from the same seller, I guess to profit from consumers who don't research much?)

reply
Aurornis 2 hours ago
Aliexpress is on a different level of misleading sales and discounts. I remember visiting the Aliexpress subreddit after trying and failing to use an Aliexpress coupon that I thought would be simple to use. The joke was that with Aliexpress the prices are made up and the coupons don’t matter.

The only method I’ve found to work with Aliexpress is to add each item from each vendor to cart and get all the way to checkout to see what the real price will be. It’s a lot of work, and then I discover they all end up about the same price with discounts factored in and feel stupid for getting tricked into playing their game.

reply
madibo3156 15 minutes ago
But, even then, it matters what order you add items to your cart.

Recently I had a—I forget what it was called—sort of "first item" discount. I was ordering three different items from one storefront, but only one would qualify for the discount, and the discount varied per item. How it determined the eligible item was based on which was added to the cart first.

I had to remove the less expensive products until the highest discount one remained in my cart, then add the others back, for the maximum discount.

reply
drdexebtjl 8 minutes ago
[delayed]
reply
hermitShell 34 minutes ago
Exactly, avoid all 'sales events', bundles, welcome deals etc. Just try to find cheap products at their normal price. It is still worth it for some things.
reply
baby_souffle 2 hours ago
I used your site to find some actually good deals this past 11.11. Thank you!

Was able to find some similar deals on slick deals and that was useful as a second point of comparison

reply
yathern 2 hours ago
Thank you!! Let me know if you have any feedback or suggestions. I try to ride the unicycle between overly technical and autopilot for casual users, still trying to find the right balance. Recently added support for Amazon coupons - trying to get email alerts in the next few days (EG "Email me when a PC with these specs or greater is cheaper than $250")
reply
InsideOutSanta 47 minutes ago
Super cool website! Now that local LLMs are getting ever better, would you consider including 64 and 128 GB models in the LLM section?
reply
akudha 3 hours ago
I've mentally tuned out of words like sale, discount, deal etc when I see them while shopping. It seems most things are on sale most of the time - how is that even possible? As much as I think Apple is arrogant, at least they don't do this crappy "sale" thing. Right now there is a whole page of "deals" on Microsoft https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/store/b/sale

Walk into any store (JC Penny etc) half the items are on sale. Even groceries - go to Safeway, there is a newspaper style coupons - multiple pages. This whole thing is just bizarre and tiring.

reply
muvlon 3 hours ago
In the EU, there is now legislation that requires vendors to show the lowest price they offered for an item in the 30 days before the "sale". So you'll see something like

20% Off! 8€ instead of 10€ (lowest price in the last 30 days: 5€)

and you know it's a junk sale.

reply
Schiendelman 38 minutes ago
Amazon has done this for a while - there's a button next to the price to see "price history". It's excellent.
reply
marginalien 2 hours ago
This is a brilliant piece of legislation. Great example of EU delivering on its promise of consumer protection.
reply
loloquwowndueo 2 hours ago
That’s awesome, what baffles the mind is they still do it because some people still fall for it
reply
moi2388 2 hours ago
Should be A year.
reply
VLM 17 minutes ago
I'm old enough to remember the workaround for 1970s stagflation which was the model number becomes a serial number. This extended into computer hardware and software of the era.

Technically model 20261116 has never been sold before and is on sale for $10. Please ignore that model 20261109 regular list not on sale price was $9.

It dovetails well with shrinkflation, make the product 10% smaller and lower the price only 5%.

reply
jerlam 2 hours ago
JCPenny infamously tried to eliminate perpetual sales when they hired the leader of Apple's retail stores, Ron Johnson, as CEO, in 2011. It turned out poorly when the customer base of JCP was unlike Apple's and really enjoyed the thrill of getting a deal, and Johnson was fired in a few years after falling sales.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ron_Johnson_(businessman)#JCPe...

reply
10111001 2 hours ago
> JCPenny infamously tried to eliminate perpetual sales when they hired the leader of Apple's retail stores, Ron Johnson, as CEO, in 2011. It turned out poorly when the customer base of JCP was unlike Apple's and really enjoyed the thrill of getting a deal, and Johnson was fired in a few years after falling sales.

I wonder how much of that was conditioning customers to believe something that wasn't on sale was a bad deal.

People don't have an "actual price" database for many items in their heads, so we have to make decisions based on heuristics. One valid heuristic is: "everything at this store is marked up 2x, so if it's not at least 50% off, I'm getting ripped off." It's really hard to get people to change their heuristics, and it takes a long time (time which you may not have).

And I have an anecdotal experience: I went to a JCPenney for another reason, and on impulse grabbed some socks I needed. When I got rung up, the socks were unexpectedly expensive. The clerk said they weren't on sale this week so they were a bad deal. I abandoned the purchase.

reply
jerlam 38 minutes ago
> People don't have an "actual price" database for many items in their heads

Yes, JCP products are completely different than Apple products.

An iPhone is an iPhone regardless of you buy it at Apple, AT&T, Target, or Amazon. So people know exactly the actual product and price.

But clothes look all the same even if their quality is dramatically different. People struggle to tell the difference between name brands and store brands even when they can physically inspect the product, and most stores have their own unique sub-brand that cannot be compared to any other products. This is why fast fashion and eventually drop shippers like Temu have been successful.

This has also been happening for a long time in the mattress and TV markets, where no one can compare prices and "look and feels the same" becomes "basically the same".

reply
al_borland 2 hours ago
I always thought they should have given him more time. It takes time to do a complete 180 on a brand image and find new customers. The existing JC Penny customers and previous CEO clearly weren't working for the business, otherwise they wouldn't have brought Johnson in to try and flip the business on its head.

I would be a customer of Johnson's version of JC Penny, but not of the one that is built on coupons and pricing games. But I don't shop as a hobby, so maybe I'm not the target market for any retailer.

reply
cwnyth 2 hours ago
I'd bet that they didn't want to be another Sears. People like you and I, I think, are in minority when it comes to consumer behavior.
reply
TheBolivianNavy 2 hours ago
It's a shame that straight-forward pricing didn't work out for JCP. I loved it.

I hate shopping. I just want to buy the same plain clothes every time and not worry about timing my purchases to sales or what combination of products qualify for a discount. As someone who needs tall clothing, it's usually a miracle to actually find things in stock and JCP actually had a good big and tall section.

reply
ajcp 2 hours ago
> Johnson's actual execution, however, was described as "one of the most aggressively unsuccessful tenures in retail history".

Big ouf of a quote.

reply
chrisnight 11 minutes ago
One thing that got me recently is that Micheal’s always has a 30%+ off coupon that you can find on their website with no login and no restrictions. The implication being that anyone who didn’t know about it just pays a 30% markup by default.

It’s really unfortunate the lack of good faith pricing nowadays.

reply
directevolve 35 minutes ago
Sales can give us permission to shop and exceed their budget, and make us feel smart for discovering a hidden opportunity.

Shopping and “deal”-hunting are fun activities for many people. It can be social (go with friends, or tell them about your favorite shop/product), self-expressive (show your discernment or imagination through what you buy), exciting (a treasure hunt), soothing (a familiar, structured process).

And why not? Shopping is how we discover the economy, one of the most mind-bending social structures there is.

Yet I, like you, find shopping tiring. Too many objects, it’s hard to find what I want, I get paralyzed trying to do price per unit weight conversions between ounces and grams, I get cynical about the “deals,” and everything starts to look the same to me. My hobbies are mostly centered on technology and information, and mostly require a few big deliberate occasional purchases. Books, gadgets, or subscriptions to data sources and digital tools are probably my biggest impulse purchases, and they can add up, but the shopping itself doesn’t take up much of my time.

My wife is the opposite. She’s a cook and loves to grocery shop to pick the best produce or find a new ingredient to try. She will spend 45 minutes searching for a new restaurant, and spends lots of time on instagram (half ads) or Facebook Marketplace. She loves going to farmstands because it feels like a discovery, and uses deal-finding apps not just as a way to feel like she’s saving but as a way to add a “side quest” (as we affectionately call them) to her day. She has various tangible hobbies (plants, crafts, pets) all of which require material inputs. I benefit from this because she adds a lot of beauty to our home and variety to our lives that I know from experience I won’t manage on my own. But it has also required communication to figure out how to get us to budget better and not turn everything into a shopping excursion.

reply
aardvarkr 3 hours ago
I heard from a Whole Foods exec that their strategy is to have a “sea of yellow” when you walk in the store. Clearly it works, otherwise everyone wouldn’t do it. Folks love a good deal, even if that deal is the actual price, and will increase the frequency that they come to your store to see what is on sale next.

I just backed a tennis ball machine that was offered at 55% off intended retail price, only to find it was listed online immediately after the campaign for the exact same price, and I felt betrayed.

reply
akudha 38 seconds ago
Clearly it works, otherwise everyone wouldn’t do it

I dunno, maybe everyone is doing it because they have no choice? If every store in the shopping mall is doing it, then what choice does a new store that just opened in the same mall have?

Or maybe nobody in management positions who make these calls want to even try something different? Afterall, we are in an age where most people in management don't think beyond the next quarter...

reply
al_borland 2 hours ago
The problem with this is we end up with completely made-up original prices, that do nothing but serve as an anchor to manipulate people.

Watch start-ups are notorious for this. They'll post insane original prices to make the watches appear higher quality, and like they are playing in a different market... these are almost always cheap watches from China that should cost $50. No one ever pays the original price, and no one should. They shouldn't even pay the listed sale price.

reply
VLM 7 minutes ago
Kohls Department Stores (regional, midwest) did this strategy of endless eternal sales and it filtered out everyone who can't stand that behavior, anyone who hates that never shopped there. A small fraction of the population shopped there, recreational shoppers, mostly retired women. Then they tried getting rid of "Everything's eternally on sale" to lure regular customers back, which efficiently got rid of the subpopulation of customers they had, leaving them with no customers. So they brought back sales and coupons, which are strongly WWII-gen and boomer-gen coded.

I personally hated shopping there, because if I wanted a pair of shoes, its like a casino, roll the dice could be $159 this week could be $39 this week, who knows? This lured in another demographic subpopulation who really enjoy gambling, and bragging about their wins while not mentioning their losses ...

reply
ToucanLoucan 2 hours ago
[dead]
reply
Anon1096 2 hours ago
Apple is one of the trailblazers of this strategy through the evergreen "student" discount that is very easy to get and saves you $100+ depending on what you're buying.
reply
wry_xy 2 hours ago
They changed it recently. You now need to verify you're a student.
reply
al_borland 2 hours ago
Apple doesn't generally advertise their ongoing student discount. Most people have no idea it even exists. I've told dozens of people over the years, no one had any clue.
reply
curun1r 2 hours ago
> As much as I think Apple is arrogant, at least they don't do this crappy "sale" thing

Apple has, for many years, done “back to school” promotions in late-Aug/early-Sep. These are legitimate deals with the student discount and a gift card or free item on top of it. However, these promotional periods very frequently happen less than a month before new product announcements and spec bumps in late-September, so they’ve effectively dumped soon-to-be-outdated inventory on students under the guise of a deal. It’s a different sort of scummy behavior.

reply
Terretta 2 hours ago
There's a reason Apple resale values (and trade in values) sustain like they do.

It's hard to argue that maintaining that resale value is scummy for the students who bought on discount when they get a job and want to upgrade. (Recently Apple even raised trade in values within the same cycle, while the new price didn't go up.)

Perhaps this is a frame of reference short term versus long term thing.

reply
everdrive 3 hours ago
The bigger question is why consumers still think that "sales" mean anything whatsoever. The rug has been pulled so, so many times. It's not even as if the prices are particularly the problem. Items on Amazon tend to be fairly cheap. Paying $10 more than the historic low for a chainsaw on Amazon doesn't really matter to me. The much bigger problems with Amazon have already been discussed ad nauseam: the meaninglessness of review scores, the shared inventory, the counterfeits, etc.
reply
arbuge 3 hours ago
One big issue with Amazon reviews is that people who never actually purchased a product can still leave reviews on them. The only difference with actual purchasers is that the latter get a tiny note on their review saying "Verified Purchaser". I'll hazard a wild guess that most people browsing on the website pay no attention to those. In any case, the total review score and star rating at the top of the listing, which everyone definitely pays attention to, is computed on the aggregate. Nobody is scrolling through a thousand plus reviews and working out in their head how many are verified purchasers and how many not.

Frequently disgruntled customers will leave dozens of one star reviews on a seller's entire product line because they didn't like one single product. Arguably competitors of that seller could be doing that too. There's nothing to stop them. The reverse presumably works too and many defective products could be getting shady five star reviews. Allowing only verified purchasers to review products and deleting all unverified purchaser reviews would go a long way towards fixing things and re-establishing customer trust IMHO.

reply
ceejayoz 3 hours ago
The verified purchaser thing must work a little bit; it's behind both the "leave a five star review and get a gift card" thing a lot of sellers pull, and the "random cheap shit showed up on my doorstep unexpectedly" scam (https://www.amazon.com/gp/help/customer/display.html?nodeId=...).
reply
mystifyingpoi 3 hours ago
"Sales" is beneficial to the customer, and can meaningfully save you money, but only if you know the market, the usual prices, alternative offers in other shops, maybe the used market, the historical behavior of certain stores etc.

It also started to became meaningless in many contexts, for example in Poland the 2 main supermarkets started selling butter for much lower price if you buy a 3-pack - it turned out, that barely anyone buys it outside of the sale. So the sale price became the actual price we care about.

reply
RicoElectrico 3 hours ago
Then again, Poland is pathological in that regard (cue comparisons with Germany where constant low prices are preferred to "sales")
reply
AdamN 2 hours ago
There was an interesting blog post about Austria vs Germany on this in this regard (can't find it). Austrian grocery stores have lots of micro-sales (juice 20% off) on any given day and those prices are in fact cheaper than they would be in Germany for the same product.

Germany had lower prices in general but if you stuck to sale prices, Austria was cheaper. The thinking is that Germans will recognize a more expensive store and not go there again even if some stuff is cheaper sometimes. Austrians are unconcerned and if they are price sensitive will buy what's on sale and just wait (and if they're well to do then they can have a different experience in the same store of just buying what they want when they want it).

reply
JTbane 3 hours ago
This is why I love going to Aldi in the US- no coupons, no sales, just low prices for decent quality.
reply
SoftTalker 7 minutes ago
They have their "Finds" which are kind of like sales (usually appears to be overstocks they probalbly bought at a deep discount).
reply
dfxm12 3 hours ago
No apps/loyalty card, so no creepy behavior tracking or selling, etc...
reply
lotsofpulp 2 hours ago
Because people want to feel like they got a deal, it boosts their ego. It’s not about actually getting a deal (for many).

Hence the failed JCPenney straight forward pricing experiment:

https://time.com/archive/7101886/why-jcpenneys-no-more-coupo...

reply
stevefan1999 8 minutes ago
You will have to understand that amid the current K-shaped economy and a heavy tilt towards AI investment buildouts, compounding on the fact that borrowing costs are way higher in the last few years (it is slightly lower, but it is expected to hike rates three times consecutively in the upcoming FOMC meetings), there are very little money left for the small businesses, that interest rate and inflation kicks in, so there are also very little budget to make a big discount, i.e. be a loss leader. In black Friday you want to trade a small loss on the goods to gain some chances that customers buy other stuff together to hopefully coup up the loss, if not, then see it as a once-in-a-year goodwill. You just no longer have that goodwill money in a more hardcore economic environment and heck the outlook is even worse.

For big business brands like Costco or Walmart, not so sure. They have stable income and they can issue investment grade corporate bond, so they don't need to use black Friday as a marketing gimmick, they could do this all day every day if they wanted. It's just the cost to acquire customer is different and they have the volume to amortize the cost

reply
getfacl 3 hours ago
I've been an Amazon customer since they only sold books. However, I have cut way back on my shopping with them.

One of my resolutions this year is to always search for independent sellers (online or brick and mortar) to compare before buying products on Amazon. In nearly all cases I have found a webshop with a better selection and a lower price, even after paying shipping.

reply
6DM 2 hours ago
I would love to buy from more small businesses. The biggest hurdle that usually pushes me away is they don’t have a clean 30 day return policy like the big box stores.

So you have to be REALLY sure that you want that product and/or be ready for the hassle of trying to get your money back.

Credit card companies are also not nearly as ready to back you up as they used to. So when the store violates its own terms, you’re going to have to go through a whole process to “prove” it to the credit card company.

So much hassle, I still try here and there but that’s what steers me clear of smaller shops.

Unfortunately this is starting to filter in on Amazon too. So now I need to look for sold/shipped by Amazon to make returns easier.

reply
Aachen 48 minutes ago
Something tells me you would like the EU. It's 14 days minimum instead of 30 but for me that has always worked (if I don't have a chance to even look at the product in the next weeks, it would be silly to buy it now and start the 2y warranty timer etc.). Never needed a credit card to get money back either, not sure if that's backed up by any legislation though. Save for scam store websites (though I have yet to come across one when not specifically looking for it), you can shop with these baseline expectations at any store in I think the European Economic Area but definitely at least the Union countries
reply
boringg 2 hours ago
That and time to discovery.
reply
tehlike 2 hours ago
I operate https://pricetracker.wtf and m if you are not using camelcamelcamel.com for Amazon, you are leaving money on the table. For folks with plenty of income, it's probably a rounding error, but in general, the prices you can get by waiting a few weeks etc can be 30-40%>

Also most things you can find on AliExpress for cheaper. Don't do edibles, beauty products etc though. I limit my purchases to tools and electronics

reply
thefourthchime 6 minutes ago
Very cool website. I got a curiosity, how is this implemented? Do you literally just scrape hundreds of thousands of prices every week?
reply
krmmalik 22 minutes ago
This doesn't seem to work for shortened Amazon share URLs in the UK. Here's an example: https://amzn.eu/d/090eTeud
reply
ramraj07 9 minutes ago
Amazon doesn’t allow using its APIs to compare prices across sites so camelcamelcamel is your best bet.
reply
tehlike 16 minutes ago
Our amazon support is sadly iffy, and it's US only. (see my other comment too).
reply
rancar2 2 hours ago
Thanks for sharing. I’m wondering what your thought on my impression of CamelCamelCamel here and the dependency it has on Amazon’s policies/practices.

CamelCamelCamel is controlled indirectly since it is only allowed to do and report as Amazon permits it via what it does and does not provide in its data feed. Amazon's API does not update in real time or provide all data points. Flash sales, Lightning Deals, and rapid algorithmic price changes often expire before the API refreshes for its inclusion and Camelcamelcamel then actually misses the lowest prices. Amazon's API usually reports the price of whichever seller currently holds the "Buy Box" which its current in court for manipulating via multiple means that may not be legal in various jurisdictions let alone ethical. The exception just pile up here…If Amazon runs out of stock and a third-party seller takes over at an exorbitant price, the chart will show a massive price spike even though the item's standard retail price never changed. The Amazon API reports the public base listing price, and never captures "clippable" green coupon boxes, Prime-exclusive discounts, or checkout promo codes. Third-party sellers frequently delete an old listing (swapping the product altogether) and create a brand-new product ID (ASIN) for the exact same item. This wipes the price tracking history from Camelcamelcamel and starts a new tracking item. Sellers can often edit the "List Price" or "Was" price field on a product, which can trigger inflated MSP price. Marketplace are always messy, but I think we will see that at this scale without adherence to its leadership principles, Amazon is going to find itself more regulated overtime to be more fair to all parties involved, as it’s unable to behave ethically independently and has repeated shown and displayed its inability to do so overtime.

reply
tehlike 32 minutes ago
Yes, there are few things that may also not be obvious.

The reason camelcamelcamel still exists is amazon gave them a special permission. Amazon affiliate program which allows CCC monetize their links does not normally allow for price tracking / alerting functionality without special permission from them, and they don't let you store information for more than 24 hours. Amazon API request limits are also pretty low, unless you can drive significant volume, and for a price tracking site, this is essentially catch-22. Without volume, the skus you can track are limited. Even with volume, they still cap you at a number i don't recall right now. They have banned my account as pricetracker.wtf was doing tracking/alerting and i wasn't fully aware of this restriction. I eventually got it unblocked, but had to criple/remove this functionalyt for amazon links, which essentially is the most important thing due to incidential purchases people make on amazon (ie people buy stuff from amazon every 1-2 days, so if they click on a link on your site, that's enough to get some sales from them even if it's not the product they bought).

There was so much I wanted to do on pricetracker.wtf but without amazon, and SEO, it's just not getting enough traffic to make it sensible for me to spend time on.

On the seller side, amazon has strict requirements on pricing, and expect you to price lowest on their platform. You may have direct sale web site, with significantly lower cost, but amazon does not normally let you advertise lower price elsewhere. I follow a seller (creator of brainflakes that you may know) on twitter, he brought this topic up a few times: https://x.com/Molson_Hart/status/2118617556152156408

Overall, amazon is enjoying being a large platform, that's for sure.

reply
mac-attack 2 hours ago
Digging the privacy-centric perspective of your site, but perplexed that it then proceeds to only allow Google sign-in...?
reply
tehlike 2 hours ago
I decided not to keep user passwords even in hashed forms, and deal with the complexities of resets etc. and kept my attack surface small.

And given how little traffic I get, I guess it doesn't matter!

reply
tonytamps 29 minutes ago
Magic link auth instead? Seems popular these days for similar reasons, though the user experience is worse.
reply
gavin_gee 4 minutes ago
the good news you can see the fake pricing on the amazon website by just looking at pricing history - they literally put the button at the top. Every sale is a scam.

its just the new version of see price in cart

reply
cwoolfe 4 hours ago
Isn't that the just the retail game? I don't think this is unique to Amazon. The method I use to search for deals is by filtering for Prime only products (gives a basic quality check) and then filter by price -> lowest first.
reply
dan_thinks 3 hours ago
It does not need to be the retail game. This is clearly false advertising. Presenting a "deal" that costs consumers more should not be allowed.

`then filter by price -> lowest first` - this method won't protect you from a historically high "low price" being presented as a special deal. "25% off" a newly raised "list price", that in a month might be back down to it's normal pricing.

https://camelcamelcamel.com/ helps - but there should be some kind of consumer guard in place here.

reply
theturtletalks 3 hours ago
Yes this is the best way. Isn’t it weird though how when you sort by price the total number of products drop?

Also, the products you find using this method is normally sellers selling that item at a loss or break even to get market share. That’s why the seller and product have little to no reviews.

reply
rancar2 3 hours ago
…also worse than just that, the number of advertising slots jump obscenely and some of the cheapest reviewed options that most people would buy in this approach are not included i. The result.

The search tactics on Amazon are purposely misleading for consumers, and no technical glitches can explain the behavior as it is clearly demonstrating the intent to serve Amazon’s bottom line and not the customer in total purposeful violation of their “leadership principles” that they are clear violating systematic and systemically with seemingly no will to change unless regulations require it locally (which is not the case for protection of the USA consumer at least and has gotten worse under the current consumer protection which are not currently being enforced or protected).

Last but not least, if you attempt to search to correct the likely future illegal tactics, Amazon will start throttling search, not returning search, or changing over to a suggested AI search with no ability to get back to regular search display. I saw this not from one experience, but numerous overtime and it is getting worse by the month right now with no end in sight.

This goes along with their tactics to sellers on and off the Amazon platform which the ongoing and future lawsuits will show.

reply
aborsy 9 minutes ago
Amazon is +10X better than shopping from brick and mortar stores (in EU at least, which are terrible). Also, better than many other online stores. It took significant pain from my shopping experience.
reply
balls187 5 minutes ago
Minor credit--they do show you price history up to a year back.
reply
nilsherzig 3 hours ago
There should be a regulation / law forcing companies to use the "lowest price in the last 30 days" or something like that instead of whatever they are currently using to calculate the sales discount
reply
maattdd 3 hours ago
Amazon does it in France at least.
reply
dns_snek 3 hours ago
It's an EU directive. Amazon.fr seems to be compliant but Amazon.de seems to be blatantly violating it, but I'm not familiar with the German implementation.

https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/unfair-treat...

reply
nilsherzig 2 hours ago
oh thats good to hear. i hope it will be implemented in Germany soon. will be useful for people who dont know about camelcamelcamel
reply
praash 3 hours ago
Is there a definite time period where a newly discounted price is not included within the "last 30 days"?
reply
redwall_hp 3 hours ago
There is in many areas. Any item promoted as being on sale will have one day to set a very high price it will normally never be at. This is especially true with appliances and beds.
reply
jacekm 3 hours ago
There is such a law in the EU (Omnibus Directive, Article 6a). The stores are required to show what was the lowest price in the last 30 days whenever a product is on sale. It's sometimes hilarious, especially on AliExpress, to see a "promotion" when the "last 30 days price" indicates otherwise.
reply
master-lincoln 3 hours ago
There were multiple legislative initiatives in the EU called omnibus directive. I think this is used to bury laws... You are referring to the one from 2019 here https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2019/2161/oj/eng
reply
Savageman 3 hours ago
We have this in France already, prices just go up early-mid October so starting mid November the deals look still "amazing".
reply
maattdd 3 hours ago
Can you show it with price tracker ?

I've randomly sampled ~ 10 items I'm interested in, and they don't show any price update around October. But they got -20% today.

reply
hibikir 2 hours ago
There are games one can play like that on extremely seasonal items, where abandoning most sales for a month is still worthwhile, but it sure narrows the damage down.
reply
1970-01-01 14 minutes ago
Walk around a tourist trap town and do some window shopping. 20-40% on sale signs everywhere. A tactic as old as time. Simply stated: You need to know the old price to know if it is a good price.
reply
newAccount2025 3 hours ago
They are really struggling with Earn Trust these days. Their reviews are fake, their brands are random letters, their product search pages push their own stuff, you basically can’t trust it at all. At least the shipping is still fast.
reply
paimapi 3 hours ago
Just a small bit of pushback - the 'random letters' are usually initialisms for some (usually) Chinese company. So something like FHICC would be 'Fuzhou Heavy Industries Cooperative Corporation' or whatever.

It's the after effect of dropshippers who popularized this kind of cheap, solo entrepreneurial e-commerce and the factory owners realizing they could cut out the middleman. The quality you get is a total crapshoot - either it's an imitation in similar housing with much worse parts or it's very close to the original spec, you just never know [0]

[0] https://www.modernretail.co/retailers/the-rise-fall-and-pote...

reply
kotaKat 3 hours ago
... if you're in a major metropolitan market, that is.

If you're in rural America, you get screwed with week+ long delivery estimates and deliberate in-warehouse deprioritization. I can't even pay for overnight or two-day shipping even if I wanted to, I'm stuck with "standard shipping". Even with Prime. Early Prime, they paid for the two-day shipping to get shit here. Now, they tell me I should be watching Prime Video instead of buying things (including with letters nagging me for not watching anything on Prime Video).

Meanwhile, Walmart's own Fulfilled by Walmart system has orders picked in less than thirty minutes from when I slap the checkout button, and the FedEx box shows up the next day.

reply
dsparkman 59 minutes ago
Amazon is not the only one that does this. Walmart does it all the time and has done it for years. Their roll-backs are notorious for this. They will sell at one price for a period of time, then jack up the price for a week or so, then put the item on roll-back. They will then lower the price to the original price or slightly higher than it was just a few weeks before. The sale is not a sale.
reply
acomjean 2 hours ago
I remember Circut City’s “going out of bussiness sale”. The big yellow signs offering big savings. I needed something obscure so I waited till the end. Much of the stuff was cleared out, but the thing i wanted was there at a huge discount from the “original” price netting me almost no savings at all.

It seems those store liquidations are a giant scam. They seem to work though as the store was picked through.

Except tower records, I got some good metal shelving from them.

reply
10111001 58 minutes ago
> It seems those store liquidations are a giant scam. They seem to work though as the store was picked through.

IIRC, liquidations are handled by an entirely separate business from the original store operator. I believe one of the first things they do before starting is close the store and reprice everything higher (like to MSRP). Those "50% OFF, EVERYTHING MUST GO," prices aren't relative to the store's typical price, but the liquidator's initial price.

reply
kotaKat 40 minutes ago
And now, because "customers demand merchandise to buy" during these sales, the liquidators now backfill with "augmented merchandise" from other closing sales and other clearances, so you end up with literal garbage sales at the final days of most dead retail stores now.

See also, the slop from the horse's mouth: https://hilcoglobal.com/perspective/how-gob-and-store-closur...

reply
dhbradshaw 3 hours ago
Years ago, I was astonished to see a sign offering 10 tacos for $5. Clearly a bargain. Got the tacos and split them with my wife.

I later learned that $0.50 was the standard price for a single taco.

reply
DamnInteresting 2 hours ago
I remember exploring a dollar store way back when they really were selling every item in the store for $1 each. The reflex was to think "wow, everything here is just one dollar?" and it felt like a bargain. But if you actually looked at at most individual items, it collapsed to, "wait, this isn't worth a dollar."
reply
OJFord 3 hours ago
Vendors like that sometimes do it just because the average person's mental mathematics ability is... Average.

My local petrol station though sometimes has deals on say £6.50 wine like '2 for £14'.

reply
latexr 60 minutes ago
Famously why the A&M third-pound burger flopped.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third-pound_burger#Marketing_f...

reply
abeppu 2 hours ago
Are third party price trackers (eg camelcamelcamel) still reliable/trustworthy? I make a habit of checking this before buying on Amazon and it provides good context, but I wonder if a Amazon is actually always showing them the same prices I see?
reply
legitster 51 minutes ago
The irony is that Black Friday originally existed to clear out old inventory to make room for holiday inventory. They have been such large sales events in their own right that most retailers (Amazon included) actually clear and bring in new inventory specially for the day.

Amazon also used to stock a lot of off-price or liquidated products back in the early days of Prime - as they've scaled up those days are long gone

reply
ianferrel 45 minutes ago
>The irony is that Black Friday originally existed to clear out old inventory to make room for holiday inventory.

Do you have evidence that supports this claim? I don't think it's true. Black Friday is the start of Christmas shopping on a day that many people have off due to the 4-day Thanksgiving holiday. It was not about "clearing out old inventory", it was the kickoff to selling all that new Christmas gift inventory.

reply
rdtsc 2 hours ago
I call it a "Macy's" trick since that's where I saw it most often. Mattress for $1000, oh but original price is $3000, what a deal! When in reality nobody bought for the original price, it's there just to create the impression of getting a deal. I guess the trick works well enough on most people that it's worth keeping around. I remember some noise about making the practice illegal or putting some guard rails against but I don's how that's practical.
reply
myrmidon 2 hours ago
This is regulated elsewhere:

EU demands that all discounts show an anchor price that is the lowest price for that item since at least 30 days (https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/unfair-treat...).

Seems practical and sensible to me (not perfect prevention, but causes lots of delay, and going "against the spirit" of rules like this is somewhat legally risky, too).

reply
mxuribe 2 hours ago
I remember seeing that in a couple of bigbox stores like Macy's, maybe Fortunoff, JCPenney's, and others, etc. I think that's I'll call "the MSRP trick" (not sure if there is an actual name for this)...Basically the "S" in MSRP - manufacturer's *suggested* retail price - is doing alot of heavy lifting. Basically the manufacturer *suggests* a crazy highly-inflated price, but the seller is NOT required to sell it at that price point...so, the seller looks good because they "giving" the consumer a super deal. I also once heard that the MSRP is actually the selling price but only at super lux/high-end stores where the super rich go to buy, because either the super rich don't care about the price, or in some cases the offspring of the super rich don't know what a bargain is or not.
reply
praxulus 2 hours ago
>I remember some noise about making the practice illegal or putting some guard rails against but I don's how that's practical.

In the EU, the law is that advertised discounts must use the lowest offered price from the previous 30 days as the reference price. That seems fairly straightforward.

reply
ryandrake 50 minutes ago
Do companies get around this by "offering" the $3000 price for 1 second on a website at 1:00 in the morning?
reply
camhart 32 minutes ago
I wanted an orange juicer last Christmas. Looked it up on amazon, on sale for $135 when normally costs like $150 or so. I checked pricing history, outside of the holidays it normally sells for $79.
reply
patrakov 2 hours ago
My pet peeve: misleading "customers also buy these items" suggestions.

Latest example: I bought a Calibrite ColorChecker Studio spectrophotometer. Amazon suggested that a photo camera calibration target is a good addition, and offered a Mini ColorChecker Classic Target as an additional item to buy. I did so, without knowing that exactly the same target is included in the box. Now I have two.

reply
j45 4 minutes ago
The real black friday/cyber monday seems to happen in January/February.

Online retailers are about optimizing their profits at all times and cases, not what customers want.

People can simply not spend and it will get their attention.

Some years, theres no deals.

Inflation is providing enough boosts in profit that they might not care to give out sales to make revenue.

Retail is about creating profit, not the product.

reply
cmiles8 3 hours ago
I find you have to shop around and not just assume Amazon has a good price since, as this study confirms, they often don’t.

Some things are a good deal but lots of stuff is just 30%+ more than what it would cost at a local store or other online retailers.

Oddly it makes little sense at times why some things are a lot more and others are cheaper. With its logistics network Amazon should be able to offer the best prices, but it’s definitely not consistently the best price. Not even close.

A lot of this is driven by FBA stuff that’s just folks reselling stuff at a markup on Amazon. It’s a double whammy of higher prices and search results full of 90% FBA junk.

reply
atmosx 2 hours ago
This has been going on in Greece for years. They lie about the real price and then they add the regular price a if it’s a Friday big deal. E.g. the laptop costs 700€ but you see “30% down, ~1000€~ 700€ Black Friday”. So it means nothing…
reply
dubeyaayush07 3 hours ago
Amazon also has price history which can be used to find whether the product is actually available at a lower price
reply
dns_snek 3 hours ago
There are third party trackers but I don't think there's anything official.
reply
dd8601fn 3 hours ago
In the US anyway, Amazon shows you a link to a graph of the 90 day price history. It’s next to any sale price.

This isn’t a new accusation. Amazon started addressing this very concern some time ago.

reply
dns_snek 3 hours ago
I see, I don't think this has landed in EU yet, not on Amazon.de or Amazon.fr anyway.
reply
OJFord 3 hours ago
Interesting, it's been in the UK just about exactly a year I think – pretty sure it appeared just before Black Friday etc. events last year (I remember thinking it seemed an interestingly consumer-friendly time to launch it).
reply
latexr 58 minutes ago
It is there on amazon.fr and amazon.es at least. Not on amazon.de.
reply
AlexandrB 3 hours ago
There is now through the Amazon AI helper thing (Rufus?). I don't know whether it shows up for every item though.
reply
AlexandrB 3 hours ago
I feel naive using Amazon's own tool for this, but I still do it. Has anyone tried comparing the Amazon history with something like camelcamelcamel for consistency?
reply
clint 9 minutes ago
Hasn't Wirecutter literally been reporting this for the best part of a decade now? Here's an article from over 5 years ago: https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/blog/why-most-deals-arent...
reply
testbjjl 3 hours ago
The definition of sale changed for me a long time ago. A sale has to align with my need for the item/service and is measured by velocity in price, independent of the offer.
reply
stronglikedan 2 hours ago
I've been tracking prices on a couple of things (not on any specific storefront, but in general), and they have been creeping up lately, presumably in preparation for a BF "sale". It's all so tiring, really.
reply
hyperbovine 2 hours ago
It feels like ~15 years ago you could genuinely find amazing deals on name brand products, particularly during the 7 (or 10? 12?) days of Christmas lightning deals special that they ran. But it's been years I was anything worth buying during their holiday sales.
reply
origini 4 hours ago
That has been the issue for decade and more. Same with some corporate benefits.

If you want to buy something, use a price search engine and research the market yourself to get a good price.

reply
jayknight 3 hours ago
I've always used camel camel camel, but recently the price they have and what I see on Amazon rarely match, so it's hard to really know.
reply
amoshi 3 hours ago
Switch to Keepa, it's more accurate and faster.
reply
maerF0x0 2 hours ago
It should be just as illegal to label a "Deal" (sale, discount et al.) that contains no deal/sale/discount as it would be to label a container of apple juice that contains none.
reply
ncruces 4 hours ago
Not bad: 2 in 3 are actual discounts, 90% don't leave you worse off.
reply
nilsherzig 3 hours ago
You might not have bought an item if it wasn't supposedly on discount. Leaving you worse off than not having spend the money. Getting tricked/scammed is part of being worse off.
reply
ncruces 3 hours ago
You misunderstand my point: not bad, because I was expecting worse.
reply
darkwater 3 hours ago
If 10% of "deals" are actually worse prices it is bad indeed in any case. That number should be 0.
reply
ZiiS 3 hours ago
At least 10% of Amazon listings are outright scams.
reply
DudeOpotomus 21 minutes ago
The rug shop downtown has been going out of business for 10 years. They have $10,000 rugs marked down to $5000.
reply
WaitWaitWha 58 minutes ago
Is it still "Amazon", or just an eBay with built-in logistics?

As in, the prices for Amazon products, the article makes sense, but what percentage of the stuff on it is still Amazon? I assume (and, i do not know) that Amazon has some influence on the pricing, but not full control.

reply
wolfi1 17 minutes ago
I'm shocked, I tell you, shocked
reply
dofm 2 hours ago
Yes, pretty normal for the prices in the UK to go up 28 days before Black Friday so they can come back down in time for Black Friday to stay within the law. I saw precisely no unusual deals on anything I have been tracking the price on.

(I did find my regular pair of shoes in one of the Prime Deal Days; I basically always buy a pair at that time of year to get new treads for winter, and then wear them flat throughout the year)

reply
bix6 4 hours ago
Amazon is such a scam. They mark things up and then immediately mark it down so they can show you “10% discount”. Can we get some freaking consumer protection laws my god why is this so contentious.
reply
ceejayoz 3 hours ago
It's especially egregious around Prime Day.
reply
selectodude 3 hours ago
It has nothing to do with Amazon. The manufacturer sets the price. They raise the price before lowering it during a sale because it works. Amazon spends all this time and money telling you to wait for prime day so trying to swim against that current is much more difficult than jacking the price during a slow time of year and then having a big discount on prime day.
reply
ceejayoz 3 hours ago
> It has nothing to do with Amazon. The manufacturer sets the price. They raise the price before lowering it during a sale because it works.

Who allows that?

Amazon explicitly https://sellercentral.amazon.com/help/hub/reference/external... says it's against their policies and that they can penalize you for it.

They'll even enforce rules on your off-Amazon sales. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2026/jul/...

reply
selectodude 34 minutes ago
Ok, I’ll let every company I’ve ever worked for know that. I’ve only messed with vendor central so maybe it’s different for small fries.
reply
AlexandrB 3 hours ago
Just wait until you hear about all the other companies doing the same stunt!

There are consumer protection laws for this kind of stuff (usually some requirement of a product having to be at the "original" price for some length of time or some sales volume[1]), but retailers typically time their price changes and discounts to work around this requirement for peak sales periods like Christmas. If you catch Amazon actually immediately marking stuff up and down to create a fake discount you can probably complain to your attorney general.

[1] https://competition-bureau.canada.ca/en/deceptive-marketing-...

reply
ZiiS 3 hours ago
Wow that is much better then I would have guessed.
reply
voidUpdate 3 hours ago
reply
ceejayoz 3 hours ago
Sure. So's speeding. A lack of enforcement is functionally permission.
reply
voidUpdate 3 hours ago
Speed limits are often enforced though. Speed cameras exist
reply
ceejayoz 3 hours ago
In the US, you can essentially always do ten over.
reply
voidUpdate 2 hours ago
Which I've never understood. It's a limit. Why are you exceeding it? Speed limits aren't assigned based on vibes, they're based on safety. You might as well drive without a seatbelt or with bald tyres or thrashed brakes
reply
addaon 32 minutes ago
Even when they’re based on safety… they’re based on safety for a fully-loaded truck with its high CG, insane stopping distance, etc. I’ve never driven a vehicle whose performance to avoid obstacles, stop in a hurry, and pull lateral Gs hasn’t vastly exceeded that case… so presumedly my vehicle can achieve the target level of safety at a higher speed.
reply
myrmidon 2 hours ago
Some things to consider:

- Speed indicators in cars are systematically biased to overindicate speed (just compare with phone/satnav).

- Assuming a certain "acceptable risk" threshold, the "correct" speed limit obviously depends on traffic, road, vehicle and driver condition. So if conditions are exceptionally good (and/or your risk tolerance above average), exceeding the limit might make sense.

reply
baby_souffle 2 hours ago
> Which I've never understood. It's a limit. Why are you exceeding it? Speed limits aren't assigned based on vibes, they're based on safety.

Not really. They put up a basic speed measurement system and sample the range for a time and then find the 85th percentile and that’s the new limit.

So the speed limit is a function of how competent or, rather, in competent most drivers are in that area.

reply
naishoya 2 hours ago
Where do they do this?
reply
toast0 52 minutes ago
Speed surveys as the basis for speed limits is standard in California; exceptions for school zones and what not, and 65 mph on a freeway doesn't need a speed survey even though some freeways go higher.

Washington state is similar, except a city can have a 'comprehensive speed plan' to set limits however they want, no survey or other engineering required.

reply
wccrawford 2 hours ago
They aren't always set based on 'safety', though. Sometimes they're set for other reasons, like fuel economy. Yes, really. And some are set based on "vibes" but given reasons like "safety", but without any science behind them. Just vibes.

People think they know how fast they can drive safely, and they tend to drive closer to that speed than the speed limit. They often fail to take into account a lot of the factors, like children that might run into the road or blind streets, when they do so.

reply
ceejayoz 2 hours ago
They know everyone does ten over, so limits are set a little lower than they should be. Moving slower than the other traffic is also risky, so there's a bit of game theory involved.

I much prefer Australia's "over is over" scenario.

reply
mint5 2 hours ago
And in places where over is over one would think it simple… but it’s not!

Depending on your car model, the odometer may significantly over report your speed by even 7-10 kph around 80kph! So when you’re going “78” the car behind is pissed you’re going 70 in the 80 zone.

It seems US odometer calibration is more accurate as the leeway with speed limits means there is less risk of an odometer under reporting 1mph

reply
toast0 49 minutes ago
Odometers and speedometers have different calibration!

US federal requirements were always pretty tight for odometers, but speedometers used to be essentially required to read significantly fast (IIRC about 10% faster than you were traveling). Modern US cars tend to have pretty accurate speedometers though.

reply
bigstrat2003 11 minutes ago
Speedometer, not odometer. Speedometer measures how fast you are going, odometer measures the total distance the car has traveled over its lifetime.
reply
subhro 3 hours ago
Lots of people here are saying they can find independent shops with lower pricing. That is true, lots of times, however what makes Amazon come ahead is shipping and 5% cashback with Amazon credit card.

It sucks. :(

reply
yipinwong 3 hours ago
Always use "CamelCamelCamel".
reply
lordleft 2 hours ago
I really feel like this counts as deceptive advertising and should be illegal.
reply
nazgulsenpai 3 hours ago
You aught to see Temu. I often laugh at how everything on there, even when it's more expensive than other retailers, is 90% off!
reply
PaulKeeble 2 hours ago
camelcamelcamel and Keepa are essential tools for dealing with Amazon, a lot of companies doing dynamic pricing and dodgy sales tactics on it. Amazon is a very poorly regulated seller generally these days.
reply
anjel 3 hours ago
Shopping on Amazon means cutting through so many dark patterns at Amazon these days, the overarching message being, pure contempt for its customers.
reply
stuxnet79 2 minutes ago
When quarterly earnings are the sole focus, only a thin line separates "customer obsession" from contempt
reply
yellow_postit 3 hours ago
Every year there are articles about retailers raising prices ahead of the holidays to then claim a discount.

If you need it, and can afford to own it, buy it.

If you can’t, don’t let a supposed deal entice your purchase.

reply
biker142541 2 hours ago
Cool to see some numbers behind what we all know already.
reply
Grombobulous 3 hours ago
Which actually means 66% of deals do offer savings.

I’m not even sure I would single out Amazon for this practice. Fake markdowns are a tale as old as time. Just look at what happened when JCPenney tried to eliminate sales in favor of straightforward pricing. Customers hated it because they felt like they weren’t getting a deal, they weren’t getting rewarded for scouting out a “find.”

reply
dingaling 3 hours ago
> Fake markdowns are a tale as old as time.

And also illegal in most civilised countries. In the UK, the claimed 'pre-sale price' must have been charged for at least 28 contiguous days in the past six months.

reply
frabia 3 hours ago
Quick tip: install a browser extension like Keepa to see price trends of Amazon products and spot the fake sales.
reply
Betelbuddy 3 hours ago
From previous experiences at Amazon, you better install an extension to detect the far few, true non fake sales.

Amazon seems to have decided, on their MBAs infinite wisdom, that because of their return policy, there was no need to police the resellers, and they would behave, under the threat of being banned. What looked like a genius idea, let scammers and bad businesses roam free, since no manager has the power to enforce rules that drop revenue.

The result was that they destroyed the brand, and outside the US they lose money like hell. Amazon is only a success in the USA.

They retreated from China domestic e-commerce market in 2019 after its market share collapsed from 15.4% to 0.6% against Alibaba and JD.com. Amazon EU S.à r.l. in Luxembourg, reported consecutive annual losses for 7 years (from 2016 through 2022). It recorded its first profit in 2023 (€281 million), then dipped back into a loss in 2024 (-€291 million), and posted a €511 million profit only in 2025 what does not have recoup 2% of their investments outside USA for the last 10 years.

Ask anybody in Europe and they will tell you, they only use Amazon where there is no other chance of getting a specific product...

reply
Havoc 3 hours ago
Just check price history?

These days I’m buying a lot of tech off eBay and aliexpress anyway. Pricing tends to be better

reply
jjyycc 60 minutes ago
That's sad!
reply
croisillon 3 hours ago
suprised_pikachu.jpg
reply
aframemodular 3 hours ago
Honestly I am surprised then that more than 2/3 of "deals" are actually deals. If you do your research on what you want to get ahead of time and what it should cost, shouldn't this still be a great day for online shopping?
reply
morelandjs 3 hours ago
Amazon exposes price history for products. You can see how much something cost under a deal compared to earlier in the year.
reply
andy_b_84 3 hours ago
They're still bad at hiding their Ministry of Truth activities, such a shame.
reply
mech998877 3 hours ago
This is not a surprise.
reply
alienbaby 54 minutes ago
its kinda one of the oldest tricks in the book. I thought there was legislation to prevent it in bricks and mortar stores, at least here in the UK. I guess it doesnt apply to Amazon huh?
reply
timnetworks 3 hours ago
The new game is marking things as one-day delivery and then taking the customers money and then not delivering on this promise.

Fuck amazon for doing that. Fuck amazon in general.

Also fuck uber for charing 'waiting fees' for the shitty taxi service, I'm not jumping into a moving car you soul sucking vampires, it needs to be stopped. Fuck uber in general tbh.

reply
master-lincoln 3 hours ago
Whenever I used a taxi I stopped the moving car, jumped in, told them where I need to go and off we went (except for Cameroon where you share taxis, so before stopping you yelled your destination so the driver could decide if they would want to pick you up if you are on route).

Isn't it more soul sucking to wait alone in a car for your customer who ordered you there and not get paid for it?

reply
timnetworks 2 hours ago
I was at the pickup point before the taxi arrived. Moreso, the pickup point was changed to the hotel about 100 meters away from where I was, because the driver was dropping off people at that hotel.

Everything was made to be more convenient for uber, not for me, and they took another 10% for the privilege.

Fuck uber.

[edit] on that note, fuck uber extra hard for raising prices on food delivery while taking ALMOST HALF from the merchant. This is parasitic behaviour where they don't care if it kills the host.

reply
unsharted 2 hours ago
I've made a hard rule to check keepa before Amazon purchases and its probably saved me thousands of dollars over the past couple years. Their practices are absolutely scummy
reply
teeray 2 hours ago
Once again, regulation. Perhaps something like “Discount percentages must be calculated from the 52-week median price of the item.”
reply
thraway3837 3 hours ago
It’s not just Amazon. It’s every retailer. This is because of timing: US holiday season/Black Friday was historically the best time to buy stuff because of deals. So people expect spectacular deals during these sales events.

However, deals now run throughout the year and prices are usually better on random days so it pays to hunt the deal sites or social media. Physical stores also have better deals and are the only authorized dealer for a lot of brands. Big hardware stores also have 2 hour or same day delivery which is amazing. And you’re guaranteed to not get fakes.

reply
ex1fm3ta 3 hours ago
In eelctronics, the items in sale tend to be different from the ones on regular prices. I saw this with powerbank, chargers, usb-c cables ... Visually it`s the same product but specification wise most of the times is quite different.
reply
prpl 2 hours ago
now do grocery stores
reply
fdefilippo 59 minutes ago
[flagged]
reply