Nvidia Was in Trouble Before the Jensen Huang Mess
74 points by Brajeshwar 2 hours ago | 45 comments

coreylane 15 minutes ago
Remember when GPUs were the dominant tech to mine crypto, then ASICs and other spepcialized purpose-built hardware came out and made GPUs irrelevant for mining, wont that also happpen in regards to ai training/inference. like aws is attemppting to do with their trainium/inferentia chips. Sure they suck now, but won't they get better and thus lose the dependency on GPUs?
reply
notnullorvoid 4 minutes ago
It's already happened hasn't it. Google's TPUs are apparently much more efficient at inference workloads. However the hardware isn't available to the public like Nvidia chips are.

I'm unsure about the energy efficiency of Tenstorrent cards, but they are at the moment much more cost effective than Nvidia. But software support is far behind, I suspect if it wasn't the cost would be more equal.

reply
bryanlarsen 14 minutes ago
> Sure they suck now,

Some suck. Google's Tensor is an example of one that doesn't, that some consider superior to Nvidia's offering. There are likely others.

reply
jack_pp 7 minutes ago
The difference is the algorithm needed to be embedded in an asic is static for Bitcoin. Models are changing too fast
reply
hermitShell 8 minutes ago
This is why I think their pivot/venture to general robotics was smart. However, I doesn't seem like they will become profitable on that front because they were outcompeted pretty hard in most measures I can conjure.
reply
itsthecourier 51 seconds ago
won't

those Asics have a fixed algorithm

Cerebras already does that an need to make a new chip for each new model

that's why you couldn't make an ASIC for Ethereum

reply
sanderjd 14 minutes ago
But why wouldn't nvidia be expected to be a major successful player in that development?
reply
nemomarx 12 minutes ago
They didn't really get into it with Asics last time, at least. Are they looking into it this time?
reply
bryanlarsen 12 minutes ago
It's Nvidia's 80% profit margin that's threatened.
reply
hparadiz 13 minutes ago
Yup. Pretty much. Any model can be a a hard wired circuit.
reply
seizethecheese 46 minutes ago
Post hoc rationalization. Nothing in here was unknown on 10/29 when the scandal broke, yet the stock market value was pretty durable before this and dropped a ton after.
reply
bluegatty 14 minutes ago
It's common for a small story to break a perspective and cause re-evaluation.

That said, Nvidia is in a strong position.

Even in a slowdown, they probably would do ok.

reply
Iolaum 7 minutes ago
Agreed, as the saying goes: In a gold rush you want to be selling picks. And they have the best publicly available picks.
reply
bryanlarsen 33 minutes ago
Which is very typical. It's one thing to recognize a bubble; it's another to predict when it's going to pop.

There were lots of traders who lost a lot of money betting against the housing bubble pop in 2005. The bubble was front page news on the Economist in 2005. Michael Burry made a lot of money because it took him a couple of years to assemble the money to be able to bet against the market and so he got lucky on the timing.

Or as the aphorism goes: the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent.

reply
MyHonestOpinon 29 minutes ago
Isn't there a bit of popular wisdom that goes like this? "If you want to time the market you have to get two bets almost perfectly right. When to get out and when to get back in"
reply
NooneAtAll5 38 minutes ago
almost as if it's a bubble...
reply
louthy 32 minutes ago
Or, the CEO who’s been at the helm during a long period of success has been fired, making future success uncertain. Perhaps?
reply
stetrain 2 minutes ago
The share price slide happened before the resignation. Uncertainty, sure, but if the only change were that Jensen had not yet resigned as of today, that uncertainty would still not be resolved.
reply
bluGill 19 minutes ago
Many companies have continued being successful through CEO changes. Many others have not. Many successful CEOs have suddenly made some bad decisions.
reply
hlynurd 25 minutes ago
Don't bother
reply
sigmoid10 39 minutes ago
People have claimed that competitors are catching up for a long time. But these journalists never understood why Nvidia was so dominant. And it seems they still don't. The Jensen story only made investors unhappy because of the high volatility and uncertainty. Noone who's well informed dumped Nvidia because of technological fears of competitors.
reply
Miner49er 31 minutes ago
Then why has it been trading at such low levels, since even before the Jensen stuff?

It's forward P/E has been well below market average for a while now.

reply
mixmastamyk 14 minutes ago
Fears of the bubble have reduced prices significantly across the sector for quite a while. Micron has a P/E of something like 5, Super micro as well.

Also for Nvidia, when a stock reaches number one and gets up to a few trillion market cap, there is hesitancy, same happened to Apple at times.

reply
bryanlarsen 30 minutes ago
OTOH developers keep confusing R&D vs production. Nvidia is going to keep its dominance in R&D. But the vast majority of Nvidia chips are used for training and inference. Using Nvidia for that saves you 3 days of work porting from R&D to production.
reply
trollbridge 15 minutes ago
Nvidia chips still have the best ratio of price to performance, so there’s not much motivation to buy anything else.
reply
bryanlarsen 40 seconds ago
You can't buy Tensor or Cerebras as a consumer.
reply
hsnewman 25 minutes ago
It's in a bubble, prepare to have the market collapse.
reply
voidfunc 23 minutes ago
Headline: Market goes down 20%

Internet: The end is near! The market is collapsing.

Investors: Well I was up 100% but now I'm up 80%.

reply
soperj 14 minutes ago
> Well I was up 100% but now I'm up 80%.

That's bad math. If you had 100k invested, and you're up 100%, then you were at 200k. A 20% drop leaves you with 160k, and you're only up 60%.

reply
voidfunc 12 minutes ago
You're right, I suck at math. Still up!
reply
lenerdenator 22 minutes ago
Well, I don't have a subscription to Wired, so it would seem I can't read this, but the lesson I draw from this is that no one person should be so important to your company's value that them making human mistakes drags the stock value down that much. No single human is that smart or that valuable. It's the job of boards to prepare for eventualities like this. Nvidia was in a better position than most to be able to do something about Huang's conduct, but now they're having to make up a succession plan as they go along.

If you own shares in a company like that, you need to evaluate how that can be changed - either your ownership of the shares, or the corporate governance of the company.

reply
bagacrap 11 minutes ago
> It's the job of boards to prepare for eventualities like this.

The board is the one who ousted him! I agree that they should have been better prepared, but from the outside this looks like a long-running power struggle. Jensen didn't accidentally wind up with 60 reports. The board finally found an opportunity to correct the issue.

reply
lenerdenator 2 minutes ago
To me, this smacks of having to cater to Huang's desire to be the "special boy". The board had actual power over him (a thing that many founders have unfortunately learned since to avoid) but at the same time, they never actually made him sit down and set up a succession plan, and never set up a board president/chairman until last week.

If they had forced him to do either of those things, it might have suggested that he was... replaceable.

reply
wilsonjensen 34 minutes ago
This whole thing just feels like different sides competing; no question there are "journalists" with short positions.

Not saying this author does. But senior leadership at Wired?

Everyone just using an obfuscated form of Elon's "GAMESTONK" strategy to boost their position.

reply
bagacrap 8 minutes ago
Shorting is really really hard. And the end goal of shorting, sure for someone it's self enrichment, but why it's tolerated as a whole is to help identify and pop bubbles before they get out of hand.

Journalists plausibly have the same goal: speak truth to power to protect society. To be an investigative reporter you take on immense amounts of personal risk, and on very rare occasions get a big payoff in terms of recognition and career prestige.

So Wired is "short" Nvidia only in the sense that they benefit from pointing out its problems, and mostly only if they are right and get the timing right, otherwise they just lose status.

reply
empath75 35 minutes ago
There's a simpler explanation for the stock price drop here. The price had almost gone up 5x in five years, and bad news caused people to stop and take profits. You don't have to assume their business model is bullshit or that the AI bubble is popping or that there is fraud to justify a 10% pull back after a run up like that.

There's so much projection and wishful thinking about completely normal price movements in hyped stock.

reply
shevy-java 50 minutes ago
> A key role enabling the AI gold rush thanks in large part to its recently ousted CEO Jensen Huang.

Well - I think the article kind of conflates the problems here.

First - I don't call it "AI gold rush" but instead "AI mafia rush". After all the RAM prices have exploded. Why do we have to pay more because of these gangster companies? Why are governments not doing anything about it? But this is a separate discussion really.

Second - I feel that the "Jensen Mess" is a strange expression, because ... which mess exactly? Does the article refer to NVIDIA having problems? Or does it refer to Jensen and his unstoppable affection for multiple ladies at the same time? Or is it not because of the female non-spy (though, do we know that) but the female spy (though, do we know that)? How many more ladies are part of the Jensen story here? Only two? That's not a very high count. I'd expect more to be revealed here. (Youtube already has tons of Jensen-memes, so he coined these, indirectly.)

To me this reminds me a little bit of the issues with regards to Kevin Spacey. Now - the situation is not the same, because personally I think Kevin is a bit creepier here, so this is not 1:1 comparable. But Kevin also is a great actor, he coined numerous iconic scenes (L. A. confidential, Usual Suspects, or my favourite being his performance in American Beauty); and Jensen also was highly successful with regards to NVIDIA. Or, we can also take Michael Jackson - I do not think anyone doubted his skills with regards to art, music and expression (dance), but many may remember the awkward connection he had with some children. These situations are all quite different, but what exactly does the article mean with "The Jensen Mess"? The sex life seems to always be of more interest than other things. That was also the case with Bill Clinton.

reply
piltdownman 38 minutes ago
// Why do we have to pay more because of these gangster companies? Why are governments not doing anything about it?

Because they're being supplied with the means to realise the Panopticon.

GCHQ in particular are chomping at the bit to be able to utilise all that lovely mass-data gathering they pulled from their fibre taps into Europe.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tempora

// what exactly does the article mean with "The Jensen Mess"?

He facilitated a massive circumvention of a strategic export ban to China and played a key role in their ability to distill IP and Advantage from the US AI Companies.

His major gaffe was allowing the public a view behind the curtain to see Oz as human and fallible - and thus the custodian of $2 Trillion of market worth as unsafe. Vitalik Buterin ain't ever falling for a honeypot by comparison.

reply
adrian_b 4 minutes ago
> He facilitated a massive circumvention of a strategic export ban

This lacks an "allegedly".

For now, even if I also believe that it is very likely that he facilitated a circumvention of the export ban, because that would have been profitable for NVIDIA, no evidence whatsoever has been presented publicly to support this, only pure speculation.

reply
skulk 36 minutes ago
> Why do we have to pay more because of these gangster companies?

This is the free market; demand is high and supply is limited so price goes up. Don't like it? Start making your own and benefit from the higher prices!

reply
dgellow 19 minutes ago
It’s very likely the limited supply has been exaggerated deliberately by NVIDIA. That’s the whole point of the circular financing scheme they’ve developed over the past 3+ years
reply
trollbridge 12 minutes ago
Then it’s that much easier to develop a competitor.

I use Apple and AMD chips for desktop inference. nVidia is still cheaper for anything beyond that.

reply
krige 11 minutes ago
No, it's wearing the free market's corpse as a face. The incentives and mechanisms are perverted and investigations into things like price fixing are being launched though.
reply
windexh8er 9 minutes ago
> This is the free market; demand is high and supply is limited so price goes up.

Free markets can be abused. Demand, in NVIDIA's case, seems to be not all that Jensen, and the company, had been stating. If the core demand was AI companies that were being funded by NVIDIA itself - then it wasn't organic demand.

If "... at least $200 billion worth of NVIDIA AI GPUs are sitting idle in warehouses after being purchased by cloud giants that lacked either the electrical grid capacity or immediate end-user demand to power them on" [0] is true then the demand wasn't there. There's zero reason to pre-purchase a GPU a year, even 6 months, ahead of build. Sure, maybe Google / Amazon / SpaceX buy during build - but these companies actually build their DCs, they don't buy GPUs and store them in a warehouse for quarters on end unless something went wrong (maybe like in Finland [1]). Jensen may very well be in a lot deeper than anyone really knows. The reporting as of late has stated that commitments by NVIDIA to memory suppliers was coming in and there was likely not enough non-circular capital to cover. The reality is Jensen likely thought he was going to be the AI kingpin, having a piece of all the AI pie and that he'd have enough time to recoup his ponzi-like investments in the downstream by paying for his own products.

I, personally, don't think we've even seen the start of this story. It's probably a huge mess starting with Jensen and flowing down through his kids. I can't imagine everything was on the up and up given the scale of dollars involved. It almost feels like the affair was a scapegoat to get out of the hot seat. Ultimately time will tell.

But, TL;DR - if you think the demand for NVIDIA was completely organic, well then I have a crate of Founder's Edition 5090's to sell you for dirt cheap.

[0] https://wccftech.com/jensen-huang-financed-ai-startups-absor... [1] https://www.reuters.com/business/environment/finland-launche...

reply
SV_BubbleTime 58 minutes ago
[flagged]
reply