Yes, there are a hundred valid reasons to self-host. But 99%+ of consumers aren't going to care.
People don't even care when the cost of hosting is ~free, like a simple home server. How many are ready to buy thousands of dollars worth of AI hardware, which could very well be obsolete a couple of years from now?
If we care about self-hosting and open source and decentralization because we believe it leads to a better world, and not simply because we want to be control freaks and snobs, then we need to learn how to build shit that is actually convenient and usable and understandable to normal people.
I think it's possible. I think many people would want this, and care, if we could package it up in a digestible way.
Before that number is high, can we realistically expect non-techies to use self-hosting?
I remember trying to install apps and it was annoying for all the same reasons self hosting is these days. It was niche, only hobbyists did it, "nobody cared" and the presumption was that for normal non-nerds, phones were exclusively for calls and texting.
There are some spectacular successes in terms of the actual self hosted software (immich and home assistant) but the overall experience is still N95 not iPhone.
The part where self hosting falls down isnt the apps it's config, networking, reliability and backups.
If I tell my mom to download and install Ollama on her Mac, do you think she's gonna have any clue which model to download from all of the 5000 models she can choose from? Do you think she understands which ones will even work well on her machine? What if she downloads one that's highly recommended online but it doesn't work on her 64 GB MacBook (hypothetical example)? Because it's too too large/slow...
and can Ollama, out of the box, do actual work on her computer, similar to the ChatGPT app with its "Work" mode, and dozens of built in connectors (google, etc)?
you call this easy to use for a normal person? You just made their point. The ChatGPT and Claude apps that my mom can download, set the standard for her. Her standard of good/easy is not what you and I as nerds find easy. you need to really put yourself in the shoes of a tech illiterate person. we haven't even touched on the fact that Claude and ChatGPT ship with easy to use iOS and Android apps that sync up perfectly with her Mac.
Also, none of this is intuitive and a lot of popular closed stuff is harder to use (and vastly disliked by the very same normal users) than some popular open source stuff.
I'd even mention 'normies' want self hosted Word and Excel and regularly reject the web-based versions of them. Normies don't want streaming games but a gaming PC or console. Normies may buy streaming services like Netflix but get upset when their favorite shows are removed, so they actually don't like netflix. Normies complain about censorship on twitter and reddit and discord and would love an alternative they control, but may be unaware that's an option and seem stuck on those services and hate them.
Normies want self-hosted all the time too. Their ability to understand and do this is what's lacking. So that's a conversation on its own, but normies aren't actually happy. Form what I can tell most people hate 50% of the stuff they use right now and most of those complaints revolve around the cloud-hosted/lack of control/privacy and other issues self-hosting or federated services or FOSS apps could arguably solve for them.
This is a big conversation but imho tends to boil down to who has the marketing and sway to get you to install or use something, not that typical end users are savvy judges of software and useability working purely on merit and informed facts. Does your grandma actually like Facebook, or is she just lonely and its the lowest friction way to not be lonely? Do you really like Chrome or Word or is it just easy to get and popular? Is the big mac the best burger ever or is just easy to get and popular?
That's a mirror that hurts to look at that you just held in front of my face. Guilty on both counts, even though I try to convince myself I'm not
I mean...sure...but how convenient was that Office 365 outage? How convenient is it to find that a feature you actually depended on is gone because the company that runs your software decided to get rid of it?
It is always a back-and-forth. It is not as if centralized computing is a new idea, in fact it was the original way to use computers and people found that issues of control mattered and switched to PCs; the pendulum swung back because people realized that there are advantages to centralization (e.g. not having a failed hard drive destroy high-value documents). The cycle will probably continue for a long time to come because the advantages and disadvantages of both approaches are fundamental.
It’s not so much about being snobs as it is about not having time and energy for a second job. The level of quality you demand simply requires a level of attention, investment and involvement that can’t be provided without working full-time on it, for profit.
Telling a bunch of hobbyists that they should provide service of a quality equivalent to that of a trillion-dollar corporation if they are serious about it is gaslighting.
I'll go purify myself now.
They don't now, but they might soon.
It used to be that bad behavior on the part of our service providers was annoying because you'd get ads and spam. Nowadays the leaked data gets aggregated into apps that help government spooks abduct your neighbors. The effort remains constant, the threats it helps you avoid are getting more dire. Eventually those lines will cross.
In terms of self-hosting vs remote-hosting regular software… I mean, a lot of regular software is fundamentally about communication (social media and office suites) so that goes on the server. LLMs don’t benefit much from being remotely hosted, other than that it makes the flops run in somebody else’s machine. But that will be hard to fund in a universe where the upper-limit to what can be charged is defined by how much additional cost “good AI hardware” adds to the price of your phone. We’ll see I guess.
I told a remote model to set up strata on my local machine. With the best options for my hardware. If someone can figure out using remote models, it's trivial to bootstrap local intelligence assuming available hardware. The hardest part was knowing that strata exists.
Ninja edit: I've even had my agent tell me about suboptimal hardware configurations and told me what to do to fix it (XMP settings, having hardware in suboptimal slots). Cognitive load is simply a non-issue. The only issue is time, but in the grand scheme of things, it's a trivial amount of time to get up and running.
While this doesn't remove the upfront cost (which could be fixed with basic financing like Apple does) and physical manipulation (e.g. replacement on failure, etc.) it does lower the barrier.
Finally, there's another path I find interesting and interested to think more of which is sharing hardware locally, from your house to your neighborhood, etc. We've done this in the late 90s - early 00s with Internet and it worked really well. I think it could work great for compute.
I see a lot of opportunities in this direction, actually and most are actually enabled by the latest improvements in AI, so most of the "old" thinking doesn't apply anymore.
By that reasoning you'd also conclude that no one cares about affordable housing or having a good work life balance or having your own lake made out of solid gold.
Think of who uses local AI, it’s either
-power users upset with the limits —-cost of intelligence is going down
-people and corps that want stabiltiy —-a massive self own by the labs, this is justified
-American labs seemingly snitching on their users (wtf?) —-huge incentive for people to use Chinese inference, which is cheaper along with other benefits
Regardless, we’re talking about a subset of a subset of people, 1% of 1%. The big bet is that everyone will become AI power users. I think it’s accurate, forget openAI, fuck Anthropic, let’s look at us, the people. Entire workflows like coding have been buried, there’s no going back to how things were before. Is it reasonable to say that will happen to the other work streams? There’s no indication not, and it’s a total gamble if it’s yes
More broadly, those prompts and the responses have value. There's a whole shadow economy in China of aggregating queries across Claude (etc) and then using that as training data. It's like your entire search history is for sale.
Clould infra has typically been opaque to the provider. You run an MySQL instance on an Amazon VM and Amazon doesn't have easy access to the unencrypted traffic and what you store. Cloud LLMs don't operate that way.
AI hardware is improving at a rapid pace. By 2030 I believe a significant amount of LLM usage will be local for these and other reasons.
They release a new RTX series every two years, last time was 2022. (edit: I mistakenly quoted the year wrong, not sure why, but it seems obvious to most that Nvidia doesn't care about the local consumer market anymore)
Meanwhile major AI companies are investing in their own chips, if Nvidia wants to survive they really should not abandon consumers.
Hoping AMD steps up to the plate. Meanwhile the nextXbox and PlayStation consoles are going to have a rough time with their next consoles which will likely cost a thousand dollars or more is my gut feeling.
Regardless, they aren't planning on sticking to the two year release cadence any more which does suck.
RTX 5080 - release price $1000, average price today $2300
Nvidia also stopped selling its own version of these cards directly to consumers and is happy with letting partners and resellers/scalpers control the price.
So it is pretty obvious that the company doesn't particularly care about this market segment.
Which I think is foolish, every AI shop is making their own alternatives, it's not going to be a winning bet for them.
Almost like going back to the Arcade era except we all pay monthly subscriptions instead of 1 quarter at a time.
The quality and internet connection stuff will improve over time. The latency problem essentially never will.
Local inference gets truly interesting when the proper next-gen, natively AI and not just a repurposed GPU, stuff starts to land. Initially things like compute-in-memory and fancy flash, and later possibly the truly exotic stuff like various RMM (read-mostly-ram, for example stacked FeFET on logic) tech.
IMO there is no chance for ubiquitous local AI to happen if that means people using GPUs. But the industry is chasing all possible solutions for more efficient inference platforms, and if something like pachinko machine architecture with FeFETs ends up winning, suddenly buying a local ai inference solution in a box is no longer as insane.
(I say this as someone who would have liked a 5090...)
AMD's aggressive marketing as an AI-first company leaves me pessimistic about that.
Apple silicon says "hold my beer", which I know because i've been doing this on my 3 year old quite beefy mac studio, for example. it's good enough for many tasks.
Maybe your point is the majority of the time that's not needed, fair, then maybe the approach is both?
This is circular reasoning. We don’t have latency-sensitive applications because sufficiently powerful local AI is not profitable to entertain such applications.
But they're ignoring that a local LLM can still be very useful for any kind of repetitive task, things like categorization or generating embeddings, translation or summarization tasks. I'm self-hosting Karakeep and use a local LLM for the AI tasks like embedding.
And once you've got that local LLM running, you can start thinking about integrations with your own custom built apps.
Anecdotally, I believe the open weights local models are constantly catching up with commercial ones, but I've honestly lost track. This is a dynamic space.
Some recent tasks I've thrown it:
* Go through my blood test data (from EHR XML dumps from prior years) and give me some over-time charts for consistently-sampled measurements
* Go through my Good Articles bookmarks, epubify them, and drop one down onto my ereader each morning for my commute, then archive the offline version into cold storage
* Go through my music library, identify my most-listened low-bitrate tracks, and source or assemble a shopping cart to get high res versions
* Analyze local tax/foreclosure auctions for vacant land; grab aerial screenshots, tax data, ownership data, and compile a weekly report of things maybe worth bidding on based on some specific selection criteria (fun facts: if you're willing to accept some headaches, 5+ acres can be yours for under $5k, if you're in the right area)
* Dump my grocery store loyalty data, analyze my purchasing habits, and prepare a weekly instacart for my approval that aims to sync with usage habits. Tweak and learn volume/order adjustments over time.
* Given a KVM that can mount ISOs onto the host, reimage two old laptops of unknown status with Debian and install Minecraft so my nieces and I can have a LAN party
* Organize my music (high confidence MusicBrainz Picard matches), movies/TV shows, ebooks, and video game ROM collections with metadata and good folder organization
* Archive bookmarked fanfiction for my offline library (slowly, and respectfully, and with an actual browser. The browser is anti-bot-countermeasured to the gills, but QFN regularly solves hCaptcha and Cloudflare turnstile challenges. Once I gave it the ability to drag, it even reasonably reliably solves drag-shape captchas. A little while back it made a purchase on eBay which is NOT a bot friendly site.)
Would I personally spend time on doing most of these? Generally not. Could an LLM screw them up so badly I regret it? Also generally not. I get the luxury of a psuedo-assistant that doesn't judge how menial the tasks I send it are, and I save time. With a local LLM, my privacy concerns are far less than with frontier models, and local abliterated models are less (or just not at all) twitchy around things that frontier classifiers balk at.
I'm hopeful that big projects like Muse can help to normalize menial task offloading, and that local LLMs provide the bridge for more technically minded folks to use them even more aggressively and limitlessly (as in compute limits/subscription costs) and cheaply.
I feel like people who consider it as an option thinks of narrow scenarios vs ai is part of our life like internet is. How do you things on mobile for example with your local models?
AI is very competitive, I use various models, I like to be on cutting edge and to be productive, its the opposite from doing something permanent, and not changing, where local models can be good. I like to do things on the go, and the last thing any normal person would want is to have DC at their basement.
But I would like to have an AI that does that, like synthesize my journals and notes and provide a local personal knowledgebase I can query, things like that.
I don't think I have a good enough GPU to manage a local model powerful enough to be worth the effort just yet, though, so I'm waiting a bit longer.
For coding and bouncing ideas off of though? Yeah sure, online is fine.
Like, you know it's already happening now on Grok that they will sell influence. And it can be so effective if they already know what's inside the head of the person whose mind they're trying to change. All the sudden we have masses of people believing vaping isn't that bad for middle school kids, or that we really should just go ahead and trust Gemini with the most intimate details of our personal lives...
Yet this would subvert one, if not the main pillar of funding - which is total self imposed (of course) surveillance.
How do you things on mobile for example with your local models?
You think you will be doing those things? And if you do keep doing those things forever, won't AI be smart enough to figure it out for you, whatever needs to happy locally?Mobile is far behind frontier coding agents but they are already solving valuable problems with competitive quality and privacy, one-time payments as viable options.
However, I do think your perspective on local models is a bit narrow. For a lot of people, they want AI tools but do not need cutting edge AI. They'd prefer to just have their own AI which is capable enough and under their control. They'd run it on a small server at home and connect to it as needed for their work (including on their phone). It's worth noting that much of the consumer-grade infrastructure definitely doesn't exist for this, but one could blame the lack of consumer-grade hardware as the source of this rather than just a general lack of demand. You can definitely see people picking up on this by running their various assistants, like OpenClaw, on Mac Minis from their home. It's definitely not accessible or cheap enough for most consumers at this point, but it's also not impossible to imagine us getting to the point where it is more ubiquitous.
I'll say, personally, that I run Qwen 3.8 27B on an RTX 3090 from my home server, and it operates pretty well for what it is. I'm certainly not giving up my Claude subscription anytime soon, but it is nice to have the option and I can chat with it directly on my phone securely (using Tailscale) and using a nice UI.
Regardless, I think the whole point of these kinds of discussions is to point out that, right now, local models aren't viable, but not because they can't be viable, but because companies are actively preventing them from being more viable. I can see for myself that they work well enough that proper investment could easily push them into the "good enough" territory for many users, and I suppose it is inevitable that more and more people will end up running local models in one way or another. But I definitely agree with the sentiment that most consumers simply do not care about it. They don't want to deal with hardware, they don't want to think about software, and they're happy to pay $20 per month for a subscription that "just works." I definitely don't blame them.
We have LLMs baked directly into silicon getting 20,000 tokens/sec with low power consumption, Taalas was bought by AMD weeks after that demo. In that world, people get a new LLM only on hardware refreshes, and only after LLMs are good enough to be in stasis for years
Apple’s M7 Pro/Max if it meets promised will be very expensive, I see some enterprises rolling them out to some staff
Some language models in the Apple Ecosystem are already baked into iOS and MacOS, and its ubiquity is invisible
Thats the direction I see things going, but like not anytime soon to alleviate supply chain crunch. 2029, 2032
Niche? Sure, but let's be honest here, a lot of AI use right now is forced, which is usually a sign that the product is not actually in demand or has questionable value for users. The big, natural-language-interpreting models are also niche -- a minority of people find them extremely useful and a majority find them to be "meh" at best.
The same way you can screenshare or forward from your local Mac? Paseo, LM Studio and LM Studio Bionic all support this kind of tailscale-ish access to local models from phone apps. (Haven't tried any of these myself)
I do, personally, have "narrow scenarios" for AI. I have to use it for work, and want to be informed and engaged on that level, but I want to keep it out of my personal life as much as is practical.
If you don't, that's fine, but I reframed my mass social media use down to an extremely minimal pattern in 2014 and I am healthier for it; I intend to keep the same distance from AI in my hobbies, for several of the same reasons.
Paradoxically, for me that has involved taking the control over it that local models offer. I use the smallest, simplest things that get the job done and I try to retain my engagement with my work.
It's all pretty low-effort and low-tinkering; no more than setting up local VMs for dev work. Old M1 Max macbook, Unsloth, Pi, a model in the Muse Glimmer/Qwen 27B/Nemotron Bolt sort of bracket.
Good enough to be a rubber duck that talks back, write the minimal kind of AI-generated support code I want, and teach me how it all works.
I might one day buy an M5 Pro Mac Mini, or an M5 Max Mac Studio, or stick an R9700 in a homebuild PC, or I might just use openrouter for the few things the Macbook won't do.
I am a cynic: I believe AI has some value, but I also believe it should be a commodified technology rather than a branded SaaS subscription product, and it should demonstrate that value without me letting a couple of large corporations FUD me into pushing it into every corner of my life at once, or simply handing over control of my job to it.
It is a matter of personal discipline, for me: I am going to resist the endless FOMO of new model benchmarks, learn how it works, keep it in a box, and take it out when I need it.
I refused to use Macs for a decade because of how offensive I found it that they locked down their computers from even adding RAM yourself. But this is the direction of the tide and swimming against it will only continue to become more and more arduous. At best, we will have some Tor-like hosted AI, but I am not holding my breath or wasting my money/energy.
Obviously worse than the centralized option, and not the hobby I want. I'd rather just use Cloud tokens help me do what I actually want to do.
I exclusively use this setup for all AI usage from fixing obscure reproducibility bugs in software that once took me weeks, to compiler bugs, to kernel hardening and hardware drivers, to building a complete unprivileged and security hardened replacement for systemd in rust. Most of that was done using Qwen 27b back when I had only 2x r9700s.
There is literally not a single problem I have faced in 25 years of systems engineering that I cannot solve now 10x+ faster using my local LLM setup.
I turned down the free OpenAI and Anthropic tokens in my YC batch because I have absolutely no interest in being reliant on third parties to do my job.
Which is exactly why said power and utility will soon be BANNED under a myriad of false aegis'.
An economy that almost exclusively extracts ECONOMIC RENT from the working class, won't permit any "leakage" or autonomy.
My peers do use OpenAI and Anthropic for web platform development work, but I lead core systems engineering on enclaves and operating systems and I do 100% of my work with hardware I own on my own property. When the internet goes down, I do not care and keep building.
It seems like it just shifts which third parties you rely on. I think local inference is cool and your setup sounds dope, but you still have third party hardware manufacturers, and third party models in the mix.
What is the advantage of this over OpenRouter, which lets me select for, jurisdiction, quantization, ZDR, etc.
note: My use case can't even come close to having this make sense financially, but I understand if yours does. Either way, that doesn't make the third party argument better.
When the internet goes down, my productivity is not impacted, and I have total privacy on my work at all times. Also no rate limiting etc, and I can burn tokens freely.
In practice though, I can produce about 3B tokens/month of Qwen 3.8 Flash Next which is the model I crank almost 24/7. That would cost something like 1k/mo on OpenRouter. My setup costs about $300/mo in electricity, though getting solar soon to drop that to zero.
My entire 12u rack has roughly the same capability as an H200, though at maybe 15k all in with mostly used parts vs 50k for a used H200 checking todays ebay prices and that is -just- the card you still need to build a system for.
Consumer cards are a lot more power hungry than enterprise cards and they take up more space. I run my setup next to my dryer, running on 240v for 15% better power efficiency.
Also using transparent memory encryption on a Xeon and an EPYC for confidential and private inference guarantees no third party can offer me. Of course I can run abliterated models that do any security research I want without refusals.
Strata and Radiance are the state of the art ATM for running big MoE models on small consumer GPUs at high performance.
As for cost a 9700 is running at about 2k USD MSRP right now and the rated power is 300w.
i just calculated that it should be Per month (30 days) 380euro in my region, which is a lot after an initial 20k.
I have to say, no limits stopping sounds nice though.
$300/mo in the bay area for 1kwh running 24/7, at least until I get solar installed, then free.
> do you not fear that your hardware will be obsolete
If it never gets better than it is right now, I cannot think of any problems in software I cannot solve locally, so I am all set for a while.
Though also, the capabilities on my -existing- cards have gone UP dramatically in the past 6 months since as the local LLM community keeps optimizing.
Sure in 3 years all these cards will be a lot cheaper than I paid, but having them for the next 3 years is absolutely worth it for me.
This costs me less than a used car. Most people chase car and phone upgrades every 2 years. I tend to get something good enough and upgrade once a decade. Depends on your goals really.