Getting the mind to steer the body to steer you
140 points by jger15 2 days ago | 50 comments

alexpotato 4 hours ago
This is largely in line with Tim Galwey's "Inner Game" books [0] specifically and Zen in general.

After reading many of Gallwey's books and also Zen and the Art of Archery [1], I would summarize it all down into one sentence:

Western coaching focuses on telling your body what to do, Zen coaching focuses on observing what your body is doing.

e.g. this story from the Inner Game of Skiing [2] summarizes it well:

"I didn't tell people how to stand, shift their weight etc. I just told them:

- observe the angle of your skis to the ground

- flat on the ground is 1

- as far over as you can tilt is 10

- just feel what angle you are at as your are moving down the hill.

A young lady then came up to ask me 'So what is the correct angle??'. I told her 'There is no correct angle, just observe what angle your skis are.' "

If you prefer a video example, this youtube video of Gallwey teaching people hit play tennis for the first time is great [3] (note: it's very low video quality but excellent at showing his techniques).

0 - Gallwey's books: https://link.amazon/B00K1eqwt

1 - Zen and the Art of Archery https://link.amazon/B0326PLb7

2 - Inner Game of skiing https://link.amazon/B0igf0GrK

3 - Gallway teaching tennis https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieb1lmm9xHk

reply
nickjj 3 hours ago
> Zen coaching focuses on observing what your body is doing.

Isn't this basically how learning works for most physical things? Riding a bike, swimming, etc..

I just came back from a bunch of icy hiking in Salt Lake City (KubeCon was last week). I wanted to climb a bunch of mountains but I had no gear except rubber sole hiking sneakers. Almost every place I went had slippery ice and steep inclines, but it was all no problem. That would be Bell Canyon upper falls, Heugh's Canyon, Neff's Canyon to the meadow, Grandeur Peak from Church Fork, Lake Blanche, Donut Falls and Frary Peak. Some of these were done in the rain or after snow.

You very quickly get used to what type of traction you get on certain types of surfaces and then you make small adjustments to improve stability. It's all trial and error and very dynamic. Maybe at the start you grab bushes for extra precaution, or you go super slow, or you crab walk down just to get a feel for how your footwear interacts with the ground.

How you shift your weight along with how much of your sneaker has contact on the ground play a big factor but it's not something you can easily explain, you just need to do it and see how it goes.

reply
AaronAPU 3 hours ago
I’m realizing much of good advice comes down to simply paying attention to whatever you want to improve. The progression is an artifact of that attention.

I guess attention really is all you need.

reply
bitwize 7 minutes ago
I became familiar with The Inner Game of Tennis via a presentation by Alan Kay, who now seems like a distant echo from a bygone age, when computing technology was really intended as a tool to aid and augment human capability, rather than the jester in Thus Spoke Zarathustra as it dances and sparkles over and past us. In the presentation, Kay provides a short clip of that exact news story featuring Gallwey working with Molly, and notes that after the first few times saying "hit", Molly's arm begins to move despite her not yet intending to actually hit the ball!

I've noticed a similar phenomenon in martial arts. When I focused less on making my body do the correct technique, and instead imagined wireframe fighters similar to the ones in Smash Bros. games attacking me, and the technique I was performing was a countermove—I found that thinking about the imaginary opponent rather than my own body made my technique more correct, as my peers and instructors had noticed.

reply
pmg 4 hours ago
> I didn't tell people how to stand, shift their weight etc. I just told them: observe the angle of your skis to the ground

Oh interesting. This is very similar to how I was taught technical 4x4 driving: rather than obsessing over where the car or the trail is, simply pay attention to where each tire is and how it’s interacting with the terrain.

On difficult river crossings and boulder-strewn trails, developing that awareness made a world of difference. Once I could intuitively track all four tires, navigating obstacles became almost automatic. It felt like 95% of the skill.

reply
PunchTornado 4 hours ago
Sorry, but this theory sounds as dumb as its name. Has the feel the force Luke vibe.
reply
Ancapistani 4 hours ago
Look into interoception and alexithymia.

Just as some people don’t have an inner dialogue or the ability to visualize, some can’t (by default) perceive their own body without intentionally thinking about it.

reply
lxgr 3 hours ago
Speaking of a missing inner dialogue, I remember reading about somebody that self-reportedly acquired the capability for it spontaneously in their adulthood, simply by learning about the concept from somebody else and then giving it a try. (More recently, I remember reading about somebody essentially deriving the same idea from first principles, by coming up with "an internal mental version of ChatGPT to ask difficult questions and get a second perspective".)

Given how astonishingly weird minds can be, why is it so surprising that some fairly simple and/or woo-sounding interventions can have dramatic effects?

As just one example, the placebo effect also sounds bizarre at the face of it. We just happen to all have grown up in a society that largely accepts it as real, due to both countless studies and ultimately making its way into mainstream education. I'm not certain that I would have easily accepted the concept myself if it were novel and not yet demonstrated by empirical research.

reply
alexpotato 3 hours ago
> Given how astonishingly weird minds can be,

The video You Are Two about what happens when the corpus callosum is severed is my favorite example of how weirds brains/minds are:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wfYbgdo8e-8&vl=en

reply
ajkjk 4 hours ago
Surely the test of whether it's dumb is whether it works, and whether it works better than other approaches, and not how dumb it sounds. To hold it to any other standard than efficacy would be to pure close-mindedness.
reply
tonyarkles 2 hours ago
The author talks about Allan Carr’s Easy Way to Quit Smoking. The most amazing thing about that book when I read it in my 20s was that, while reading it, I spent a lot of time thinking about how the book was bullshit and honestly written like a propaganda piece. I get to the end, it has its little spiel about waking up the next morning and being a non-smoker or whatever the final punchline was… I shook my head, went to bed, and woke up the next morning and didn’t smoke for 2 years.

(Which… the fact that I did go back to it two years later is by no means an indictment of the book… contextual habits are such a fascinating thing in their own right. I hadn’t even thought about smoking for those two years, and then I went back to grad school and suddenly my first homework assignment has me ferociously craving a cigarette and there’s a ton of smokers standing outside the building…)

reply
kelnos 3 hours ago
That is the question, though: does it work? I don't think anecdotes from pop-sci books (or comments on HN) count as evidence. Not saying it doesn't work, but I don't think there's proof here that it does, either.
reply
leoc 4 hours ago
Harry Reasoner from the US ABC TV network was supposedly dubious as well. He famously put it to the test: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ieb1lmm9xHk .
reply
geye1234 4 hours ago
Yes, the technique for dealing with anxiety described here is pretty much identical:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lGa-jQJazpY

This stuff should really be taught in schools.

Acts form habits, whether for good or for bad. The mind and the body are one substance, two aspects of the same thing.

reply
justonceokay 47 minutes ago
Every moment of your life, you are training as hard as any professional athlete. Training for what? To be exactly the person that you have become so far.
reply
baud9600 3 hours ago
It occurs to me that if craving can be addressed one-battle-at-a-time, the opposite may be true: procrastination (or resistance to positive change) can be addressed one tiny bite at a time? I’m not sure what that looks like but it seems like an inversion of the same idea? I’d like to know more about this.

Great comments on this thread, thanks all.

reply
metalcrow 3 hours ago
This is a common procrastination technique, yes! Doing even just 10 minutes of work a day is a method people use, because it's just 10 minutes, it's next to impossible to say 10 minutes is too much work. And then you work up from there.
reply
Kheyas 2 hours ago
I tried this method until I burnt out. Laziness is actually unaddressed issues in a trench coat.
reply
dalemhurley 2 hours ago
Yep - efficiency maxing is a curse that few recognise. I know I fail to recognise The benefits of taking a walking with no headphones, just relaxing to recharge, and sleep.
reply
baud9600 57 minutes ago
> Laziness is actually unaddressed issues in a trench coat

That’s a great line

reply
jakeinspace 5 hours ago
Quitting sugar is a funny example, because for many people, some of those craving feelings might be coming from the gut microbiome demanding more of what it wants. I had to cut out most sugars/simple carbs for gut health reasons and what do you know, the cravings vanished simultaneously with the other unpleasant symptoms.

Not saying that's the only driver for sugar cravings of course, the brain and gut are in dialogue.

reply
cowlevel 4 hours ago
In other words, you're saying the sugar craving monster might be literal - there's literally a thing inside you that feeds on sugar and dies a little when you don't eat it, and that's why it's funny.

This is probably safe for your microbiome, which can do with less sugar eating bacteria if you don't eat much sugar.

reply
jwpapi 3 hours ago
There are two wolfs in you: The one that does wants what you should do and the one that wants what you crave. Which one is growing? The one you feed.
reply
shermantanktop 5 hours ago
For me, what I think of as ”you“ is not a tiny homunculus in my head which steers the rest of me with commands and controls. “You“ are not in control, “you” is a crowd of competing impulses and memories, with a thin mask on it that lets you imagine yourself as the boss.
reply
cowlevel 4 hours ago
It seems like reading some of these ideas helps the reasoning brain discover the correct signal to send out to the unconscious mind to make something happen. And in a remarkably abstract way - the reasoning brain can receive a message like "it's all in your head" and (if conditions are right) discover the signal that suppresses certain back pain.
reply
dalemhurley 2 hours ago
There are certainly a lot of truth in cure your body by mind but there are significant dangers in going too far. As a runner too often I push through the mental wall, sometimes it leads to far worse injuries. Same as a founder, I pushed through many times and the end results were not worth the cost. Balance is the key that I am yet to discover.
reply
Exoristos 60 minutes ago
I think you're talking about "mind over matter" self-motivation more than thoughts and habits that cure.
reply
delichon 3 hours ago
> The same thing happens with John Sarno’s book, Healing Back Pain: The Mind-Body Connection.

This was me, flat on my back, pretty much paralyzed in bed from pain from moving in any direction. I bought the book on my tablet and started reading, got to the part about how I was doing it exactly wrong, and that getting up and moving is the way out. That was a starter's pistol for me. I hobbled my way out of back pain and that has been my first resort ever since.

I ignored the woo woo about subconscious self sabotage.

reply
dalemhurley 2 hours ago
Yes- but all has to be in moderation and as a combination of treatments. I get people telling me all the time to do wild things which ignore the slip disks will hurt in the days after, sure I can do it in the moment but I will pay for it.
reply
Barrin92 2 hours ago
>I ignored the woo woo about subconscious self sabotage.

The woo woo with Sarno is in the physiological explanations that he gives for pain (ostensible oxygen deprivation which turns out to not be the case), but subconscious self sabotage is a fairly sound explanation for what's going on.

In Adlerian psychology this is usually framed as the teleogy rather than the etiology of pain, anxiety and so forth. Ask what is the purpose of pain or anxiety, not its cause. We often maintain pain or anxiety because its a safety mechanism. You don't stay home because you suffer from pain or are anxious, the pain or anxiety protects you from change.

reply
nuancebydefault 5 hours ago
It is indeed not willpower that steers the body most. The more the reasoning brain imposes will on the body, the more the body/unconscious protests by causing pain.

The art is instead to assure the body that all is fine, for example calming it by rithmic movements like walking or boxed breathing. After a while the body admits there's nothing it needs to fight for, the pain and cravings deminish.

reply
gweinberg 4 hours ago
I would assume someone who said he was cured just by reading the reviews was joking.
reply
lxgr 3 hours ago
Most nonfiction books present zero to a handful of novel core concepts that could be described in a few pages and then spend the rest filling pages with anecdotes, the history of the discovery etc. that, while often interesting and entertaining, are not strictly necessary to convey that message at all.

I would actually find it much more surprising if a reportedly life-changing method, which can be implemented purely by changes in behavior, would work only if presented in a hundreds of pages but not in a couple of paragraphs. (And, to be very honest, I would probably also not spend $10 on a couple of paragraphs. That's not how I've learned to model the economics of buying and reading books :)

reply
layer8 4 hours ago
Sometimes you can get all the important insights from the reviews and don’t actually need to read the book, so maybe that’s what they meant.
reply
cowlevel 4 hours ago
Maybe, but it's not completely implausible, either. If someone has written a review that contains exactly the right key point from the book, it's possible.
reply
lxgr 3 hours ago
I don't find it implausible at all.

Consider how concisely some hard-won scientific achievements could be presented to somebody from an earlier period. "Many illnesses are caused by omnipresent microorganisms that can be killed by heat, alcohol, and soap" sent back through time alone could, if believed, save billions, completely experimentally and without any theory of cellular life, bacteria etc.

Why shouldn't the same hold for psychological techniques as well?

reply
bigbuppo 3 hours ago
Sometimes all it takes is one small tool in your toolbox to make a big change. As the song says, I am downright amazed at what I can destroy with just a hammer.
reply
grebc 4 hours ago
Americans struggle with satire I find.
reply
Jeff_Brown 4 hours ago
Haha thought you were serious for a sec. USA! USA!
reply
dzink 3 hours ago
reply
astral_drama 5 hours ago
Nice techniques. And you can also let go of steering altogether. Here's an apt fight club scene for the compulsive self optimizing, self improving control freaks out there.

https://youtu.be/38FMDG7tiA4?is=2d-Vd9CWJIHsJzWK

reply
ahofmann 5 hours ago
I really like what the author wrote and I'm one of those people who was freed from their chronic back pains by just reading the first 60 pages of jon Sarnos book.
reply
vatsachak 2 hours ago
This is such bullshit. Pain is a physical signal from your body telling you that a part of you is compromised.

I believe that you can train yourself to ignore pain, but that's literally a last resort. And my experience with this was that the pain just manifests in other ways, like anxiety.

Call me ancient but I think that the reverse is true, it's easier to eliminate mental anguish through bodily improvement than the converse

reply
Exoristos 57 minutes ago
Pain is often a meaningful signal, but it can be psychosomatic as well in some cases. However, I do applaud your concluding observation that, basically, healing the body can heal the mind. Mind and body communicate in both directions and to heal or develop must work together.
reply
PunchTornado 4 hours ago
This blog post cured my back pain
reply
themgt 3 hours ago
Often in life, your body is the one steering you. And sometimes, to get to do the thing you want, you can’t just convince yourself with reason or arguments, or will yourself, or do the exercises to get there - you need to learn the magic formula, the secret words, to trick the body into acting in a way that gets you the outcome you want.

Sometimes we need to find a way to steer the body, and the body only listens when you say the magic words. I like these examples, not only because they are all actually powerful and useful, but also because it feels like I am whispering the secrets of the universe - that through saying the magic words, I am being granted special root access to my own programming.

Modern humans reinventing the bicameral mind from first principles. This is a golden retriever's inner monologue seeing a treat being held out and hearing "sit"

reply
x______________ 5 hours ago
...to quit smoking
reply
riceflippa 3 hours ago
There are MANY eastern things(not just philosophies) like patanjali yogasutras that is the framework for this, & is basically are cures for a great life, but the west(by western medical propaganda - which is big pharma + western inferiority complex) will only come to it if it is presented in a western way
reply
lukan 2 hours ago
"but the west(by western medical propaganda - which is big pharma + western inferiority complex) will only come to it if it is presented in a western way"

Hehe, that reminds me about the hype about chinese medicine. That was largely not understood in china at all, as to them it was old not working medicine and the modern medicine obviously better.

In other words I disagree that western audiences need a western presentation in general it can be the opposite, the mysticism of the ancient asian traditions are part of the package (never mind that most "ancient" traditions are in reality just decades old and just new interpretations of old teaching)

reply
kang 2 hours ago
the downvotes prove the point :)
reply