One key difference between each company's implementation had to do with the shifting solenoids and the electronics. But as far as I know the actual clutch pads and gearing were the same.
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GM%E2%80%93Ford_6-speed_automa...
All the manufacturers have been doing it since even before that, with major items like engines and transmissions.
What they haven't been doing is standardising all those other parts that need replacing. For example, standardising on the wheel hub+knuckle for 15-inch, 16-inch, 17-inch and 18-inch wheels will let wheels of the specific size use the same disks, calipers, pads, balljoint, wheel bearing, CV joint and all the sensors (wheel speed, brake, etc).
I see no reason why two different SUVs on 17-inch wheels need completely different brake pads shapes, when both sets have the same surface area, require the same performance profile, etc, but that's what we have now.
You can do the same with almost every mechanical and electrical subsystem in a car, and still have a large variety in cars produced. After all, car manufacturers don't manufacture their own tyres and batteries, do they? They don't manufacture they own wheels.
Even the things that are specific to them, they outsource anyway - they don't each have their own windscreen manufacturer, they outsource that. The already outsource all the glass, all the oils and fluids, all the pipes, etc, it's jus that they produce incompatible designs so that the actual parts manufacturer has to charge a jig setup fee for each of them. Standardising on parts brings in economies of scale.
Because an SUV that has 17" wheels can weigh two tons or three tons or more. It can do 120 mph maximum speed or it can go to 160 mph or more.
The math changes really fast when it comes to stopping that SUV down based on those two parameters alone. You can see why different calipers, how many, brake disk size, type (ventilated or not), different sized brake pads.
> Because an SUV that has 17" wheels can weigh two tons or three tons or more. It can do 120 mph maximum speed or it can go to 160 mph or more.
Didn't I address this objection in advance with the words "performance profile"?
Right now, 95% of SUVs have the same brake performance requirements: under 4 ton, under 160mph, etc. There is no cost saving in making an entirely different wheel assembly for SUVs that require under 3.99 tons and under 159mph, which is what the current manufacturers are doing.
I did not understood your statement like that.
I don’t know about cost savings, but most likely it is about design decisions regarding how a wheel should look like (brake calipers in front of the wheel, in the back).
I feel like the title is misleading on the impact, it's actually all of the big players
> The push to simplify and lower costs comes as Japan’s seven automakers, including Toyota, Nissan, Honda, Mazda, Subaru, Mitsubishi, and Suzuki, work to fend off the increasingly competitive list of Chinese automaker
Nissan is losing money, closing factories, ending model lines, and tried to merge with Honda last year.
Honda had its first annual loss since 1955 and they have no EV lineup.
They waited so long. They finally did it, with a rebadged GM because they don’t have the time to make one themselves, and it was popular. So they canceled it?
You’re way too late to start making your own, and they don’t even want to do it.
It’s like they think choosing to have a corporate Viking funeral and just burn the place down is the best way to honor their legacy. It’s nuts.
Younger generation had an edge previously because they could absorb how to use new tools, machines etc compared to someone older.
That's not the case here anymore.
Older people don't have any problem using AI. It's just AI don't need that many people. I don't think you can blindly apply what happened in the past to this case.
For some reason, people in this thread keep making this statement without providing any reason why they believe it
In a fully mechanized/automated world, we won't work. It will make no sense to work. Im this scenario we have a wealth distribution problem. How do you decide who gets how much of what? Capitalism as we know it relies on cost of labour to distribute wealth.
Now, will AI be doing this? I don't think so. So I agree with you, it's going to increase productivity of a lot of jobs, but it will also create jobs. But we don't really know.
Your entire argument rests of this statement. Why wouldn't it make sense to work? How would one company differentiate its products from another if they're all using the same AI?
Let's take a contrived example. Let's say automation can produce yachts for all of us at affordable prices someday. We're just going to all own yachts then. What will be the reason for one person to choose one yacht over another? Branding, marketing, positioning, patents, regulations, etc. Who does that work? Humans. Because ultimately you're selling to humans in a human-controlled world, not machines.
I like to imagine a new form of wealth distribution needed to ensure happy life for everyone- healthcare can become cheaper with AI for example. Could we fund healthcare for all?
imagine the increased demand in animal husbandry, tool and die making, metalworking, woodworking, logistics and transportation, storage & food processing itself.
The secondary effects of any big jump like that rarely touch one portion of life.
The objective and effect of the plow (and practically every tool humanity has ever made) was to improve the efficiency and efficacy of a single task. The objective of the AI hyperscalers is to create a tool that is capable of doing any arbitrary work. They want to abolish human effort as the last possible economic problem to solve - similarly to how cryptobros proselytized about the monetization of everything forever, hyperscalers are sticking their tech everywhere they possibly can to try and find places where it extracts money.
The argument this time around is stronger as the fundamentals are simpler and more practical and not a pipe dream. Cryptobros argued that you could "own" anything, as long as you and every other person alive agreed to jump through the stupidest hoops ever concieved and were fine with not actually owning things in any conventional sense and also you connect everything in the world to the internet because its Really Important™ that proof you bought a pack of gum is duplicated on millions of computers simultaneously. There are endless critiques of Web3 and crypto, but they all generally boil down to infeasibilty. The AI argument lacks this issue; real tangible work is being done profitably right now by machines. The uses of these machines can potentially be cheaper than paying a person to do this work. The work done may be done faster or better or cheaper (or some set of these) than if a human does it. Economic players recognize its potential value and are frothing at the mouth at the idea of never having to pay a person to do any work ever again. Employers don't want to pay people because people are generally their highest cost, and eliminating them for a cheaper alternative is their goal, and an economic inevitability.
- https://www.automotive-fleet.com/news/gm-ford-officially-sig...
it'd be interesting to see if they try something like NUMMI between Japan/China beyond the fairly simple bz3 operation they had going
Think about it like this, 15~20 years ago, each company was building an operating system: Simbian, Windows Phone, Windows Mobile, various Linux based phones, Android, iOS, Blackberry OS, Palm OS, Firefox OS, Ubuntu's Unity Mobile... But then with the rise of iOS/Android, the cost of building something for each platform sky rocketed, you could have ten people each making the same tool for a different OS, or each making a different tool for the same OS. On the other hand it was easier to write one software for Android, and install Android everywhere, instead of having ten different apps for ten different OSes, and a company could install Android on their phones and have a smart phone, the other could make a whole operating system and only when all of the Anroid apps were available to their os it would have become feasible.
So efficiency and optimization always means the death of variety. You can have many programming languages with no good libraries, or a crappy JavaScript and C that have everything available to them... We all chose the latter.
Was chatting with the local hardware store owner a few weeks back about bulbs and solenoids - there are standards, but the breadth of different types in cars on the road means it isn't worth the shelf space to stock them - individual types move slowly while stocking enough variety to cover what the local market needs takes space away from more profitable things (like metric-thread fasteners).
Even nearby auto parts store end up ordering common parts from regional warehouses, putting them on roughly equal footing with RockAuto in terms of time to delivery (and of course at a disadvantage on price).
And this doesn't even get into truly unique parts like door latch motors or the various ICs that control various subsystems.
Frankly, it's a mess. Having a spare "parts car" sitting around is best if you have the space for it.
I can't count on both hands the number of different types of battery, spark plug, fuse, or indicator lamp I've encountered.
And I've never worked on a car that was produced prior to 1979.
There were "step changes", like when headlights went from sealed beams to halogen bulbs in reflectors, You either had 6" or 8" sealed beams, or most likely H4 halogen bulbs (or a single filament bulb I've forgotten if you had separate low/high beam lights). If you had a headlight out, it mostly didn't matter what model car you had, or of it was a Ford or a VW or a Leyland, they all used one of 4 types of bulbs and they were all interchangeable.
In my head, and this is more motorcycle specific than car specific, but likely indicative across the entire automotive industry, it was the early 2000s when that started to change. My 1991 and 1998 Hondas and my 1999 Ducati and my 2004 Cagiva all used H4 headlight globes and the same 10/25W tail/brake light globes. My 2009 Yamaha was the first bike I owned where I had to buy headlight globes from Yamaha.
I've had cars with 9006/9007 headlight bulbs. Those were OK, I guess, other than the polycarbonate housings that turn into a clouded quagmire of shit when exposed to sunlight.
My 2012 Honda uses D2S headlight bulbs. That's a metal-halide part and it does not interchange with any other format, including other metal-halide parts. Each also requires both ballast and igniter assemblies. (Once lit, the bulb itself runs on [IIRC] 35V. But it takes a few kiloVolts to get it to initially arc over, vaporize some metallic salts, and start making light. And none of those volts are the ~12V that the car's electrical system produces.)
But at least it can use ~any regular D2S bulb. More-modern cars often use LED assemblies that aren't interchangeable between models at all.
But, yes: For decades in sealed-beam automobile world, we had a couple of sizes for round, and a couple of sizes for rectangular, and these sizes included the whole light-producing assembly, with focusing elements and the whole shebang. Some included a high-beam filament and some kept that separate, but: Any of these were very normal (standardized) things that anyone could pick up at ~any place selling auto parts and swap out with a screwdriver and whatever it takes to remove some trim.
(I've lived long enough to have seen sealed-beam headlight assemblies on shelves at small-town grocery stores. I have every confidence that if I rolled into the parking lot of such a store with a burnt-out halogen headlight in nineteen-eighty-something, then I'd be able to buy one and borrow enough basic hand tools to replace it in their parking lot in fairly short order. I'd probably also have paid Way Too Much for the headlight assembly itself, but I'd have been very grateful anyway. Convenience has a cost, even in matters of safety.)
I can screw in any of a whole galaxy of spark plugs into my Honda's engine, but that doesn't mean that the pistons won't collide with them before reaching TDC. (Does it matter if the screw threads are compatible when the parts crash before they can be used?)
Do we really have to talk about the light bulbs and the fuses, too? It's pretty boring, but I'll be bored later if anyone really wants to get into that.
(I'd like some popcorn, first, if anyone feels like contributing something.)
Standardization of parts is good for the consumers, cheaper to build and cheaper to maintain.
I'm not sure what general purpose robotics even is because the point of robotics is to not be general purpose, a general purpose robot is hardly faster than a general purpose human, the speed of the assembly line comes from recombining standardized parts, that's true for human or robotic artisanal vs assembly production
the bespoke sandwich shop is always going to be more expensive than the sandwich factory even if the former is operated by a bot
Yes, assembly line stuff will always be cheaper, and we'll continue to use a lot of mass manufactured stuff. But we don't always pick the cheapest option for everything. As custom options become cheaper we'll pick them more often even if they don't reach parity with mass manufactured options.
On the bright side, maintenance and repairs should become much simpler.
We certainly did fine back when all cars had sealed beam headlights and the choices were circle or the more exciting rectangle and two lamps with two filaments each or four lamps with one filament.
I could easily see standardization to a small menu of less exciting parts. Surely, every model still needs different wheels, but wheel hubs could be pretty standardized with several sizes.
If 90% of the infotainment system is identical between 15 brands and the only differences are the bezel around it, the exact shape of the knob, and the coat of paint on the UI is that really so bad?
Costs just keep going up and up. People complain about it constantly. Anything to help make cars cheaper so they’re more competitive is a plus for everyone. Even if it’s only by a tiny bit.
They are also quite behind on car software, like the Germans.
The part about keeping consistent color coding in the wires relives a mental load for repair.
I guess it applies to car as well.
That’s why there’s 100 different toothpastes that all effectively are the same.
I’ve also had good feedback from my dentist re: manual brushing and “essential” toothpaste (of which I have a national stockpile) so I will use that up before venturing into something exotic.
all these brands spend so much money in advertising just to convince people that their product (which is probably 95% the same as any other one) is the best.
what a waste of resource and money.
More seriously, I suppose it's because you want competitive markets and products can vary along multiple dimensions like price, size, ingredients / composition, ethical claims, consumer targeting, etc.
I'm reminded of one of my favourite historical Onion articles: https://theonion.com/consumer-product-diversity-now-exceeds-...
“As more and more species fall victim to extinction, we face a grave crisis of decreased diversity, not only in America but across the globe,” Hargrove said. “But the good news is, these losses in biodiversity are more than offset by a corresponding rise in consumer-product diversity. Though flora and fauna are dwindling, the spectrum of goods available to consumers is wider than at any time in planetary history. And that’s something we can all be happy about.”
Need canned beans? Fine, no worries: Baked beans, black beans, pintos, red beans, refried, whatever -- they're all on the shelf... and they're all labeled with one of Aldi's in-house brands.
It was generally the same with the meat and the cheese and the produce and ~everything else, too. Ribs? Ribeyes? Fresh salmon? They probably had it, and there was definitely only one brand to pick from -- whichever one of Aldi's house brands fit that broader category.
(It's softened somewhat in recent years. Nowadays, I can select a block of [fucking-outstanding for-the-price] aged cheddar cheese with an Aldi house label, or a competitive product at a somewhat higher price with a Cabot label. They're stocked next to eachother.)
eg. Breakfast cereal boxes should be small, medium, and large, regardless of brand (and "large" and "medium" should differ only in width). Then shelves and cabinets can be sized to fit the ISO standard cereal box with no wasted space. Same with dish soap. Etc.
General principle you bring up I agree with, but the example is interesting for this issue/reason
At least Toyota have a range of more sensible EVs now in the UK, but they seem to be squarely aiming at the large (i.e. expensive ... Tesla Y, BMW x1 prices for example) SUV market where you're never going to compete to more premium brands in a Toyota (this is why they invented Lexus after all). Where is the 250 mile range EV Corolla or Prius for example?
Curious how it plays out for nissan given they're already just reading Renaults.
I used to only buy Hondas and Toyotas in the old days but now I've switched to other brands because they sell EVs that are usable.
Toyota, Nissan and Honda are different companies.
If you look at the "one 15min stop" range, the first Chinese car to appear is the Geely-owned Volvo and only on the second page:
https://ev-database.org/#group=vehicle-group&rs-pr=10000_100...
First, a driver was about to turn as I was catching the end of a greenlight... Let's just say I'm grateful to be in one piece.
Then, the navigation got me stuck in traffic for a train crossing. The train must have been 200 cars. I lost count. As I'm sitting there missing reading my ebook on the subway, I look around at the cars. A blue Kia hatchback with the new logo, a Mitsubishi, a few Toyotas, Hyundais.
I can't help but think these brands are already relics.
A trend under everyone's nose is public transportation, and non-car travel modes, have only gotten better. For the rest, you'll have public and private vehicles that drive you, there's car share, and what remains is a much smaller rural market.
What does each of these companies have, to respond to that? Shortages and cost overruns it seems, and not much else. Nokia was a household brand until it wasn't.
It's hard to imagine Toyota having that faith. The rest, I reckon many will fall. Don't you think?
No, I think your comment comes off as a bit out of touch if you believe that public transport is replacing the tens of millions of cars that hit the roads on a daily basis any time soon.
Non car travel modes are fine unless they’re not. I can ride a bike when it’s nice outside, but when it’s cold or raining I’d really rather get into a car. Public transportation can be better if the whole city is in a gridlock, but usually it’s not, and you’re locked into preset routes. When I’m going somewhere with friends I’d rather be able to talk to them freely without third patries giving me a side eye because it’s too early or too late or omg there are little children here you need to keep this pegi 8.
Let people own things, damn it. There’s enough rent seeking everywhere.
This, 100%. Besides, car rentals are so expensive that if you need a car more than a couple of days a month, you are much better off keeping a cheap car. Uber and the like have also become insanely expensive.
We have pretty decent public transportation in Qatar but people mostly go by car and we use a shit ton of fuel while at it. Around 3 cars average per household here and closer to 5 if you only include citizens. It's all car culture with plenty of infrastructure to support loads of cars.
A day pass on the metro costs just $2 but our fuel is also quite cheap.
Not about to be taking it anytime soon.
Depending on the car, some estimates say that only the windows and tires are the only pieces that come from outside suppliers.
[1] https://www.electrichybridvehicletechnology.com/features/fea...
So JAMA (Japanese automakers’ industrial association) asked what they could do. Their answer was to standardize basic components so that they could reduce bottlenecks.
The problem there is you're comparing a Corolla to a Tesla and not e.g. a Chevy Bolt, which has a lower TCO than both.
> At the high end, electric trucks are insanely expensive and less practical than gas trucks.
There is a reason companies like Amazon use electric delivery trucks and it's not because they're impractical.
The main issue with trucks is that to give an electric truck a reasonable range when hauling a load, it needs a much bigger battery, and then to justify that you have to be actually using it as a truck full-time rather than as a truck-shaped car. Which is fully justified when you are, because then the fuel savings are enormous.
Whereas the people not really using it as a truck don't really need the bigger battery and then it doesn't have to cost that much. And even that isn't going to matter if the battery prices keep going down.
The other option which the US companies seem to be leaning into is to use the smaller battery and offer a range extender that runs on gas, which is a hybrid in a sense but it's more like an EV with a slot to put a gas generator.
Right. It's subsidies/incentives. And, of course, operating within the legal/governance structure, you can 'fine' the vehicles you don't like - have special clean air zones with fees for entry, high tax for oil/petrol, etc.
I hope you didn't mean this was something to do with costs. It's just the government using licensing, laws, taxes, etc to direct proceedings as they want - nothing to do with the underlying costs.
The main issue is that the US effectively bans imports of electric cars from the most efficient suppliers on the planet.
His interference in elections and the war in Ukraine hasn’t gone unnoticed in many markets. Tesla comes with weaker residual value because of the brand damage.
Now that other manufacturers are moving away from soft-screens towards tactile controls software UX is much less important too.
Personally, I’d much rather have “knob per function” than have to go menu diving through a GUI at 80mph.
There’s many great alternatives now that really are great value. i.e. Renault, Nissan, Skoda, VW, BMW, Dacha.
I've got no love for the cringe machine that is Elon, but c'mon. Would people really buy from a Chinese maker over Tesla based on some kind of political stance?
BMW just launched an i3 with a 567 mile range. Is that enough?
Personally I think I’d be pretty happy with 300 to 400 miles.
Range will increase over time.
There’s still lots of efficiency improvements to be made like replacing the motor, differential and breaking systems with in-wheel combined brake/motor units.
We will get to a point where EV range is greater than on ICE cars.
The price difference between home charging vs a fast charger can be extreme, 6-7p/unit vs 80-90p/unit.
Usually I charge when I go grocery shopping. I can't remember the last time I drove to a charging station just to charge.
Typical Dutch driving pattern is strongly bimodal - a lot of everyday short trips (think commuting), plus several holiday trips per year - Austria, south of France, Italy, you name it. That would be the trips where "too many hours at fast chargers" would be a problem for me personally.
It's a true statement, they don't. Yet everyone, not just people with jobs and hobbies that cause fires, still needs smoke alarms and fire extinguishers and building codes that demand multiple exits from bedrooms etc.
This "outlier" argument that a lot of people think makes sense, doesn't. It's completely invalid. Most people could actually get by with a golf cart most of the time. Except no they can't, because most of the time isn't good enough.
Ehh that's complicated. They're much _much_ longer once you get out into the sticks. In the suburbs I imagine it varies. But in urban areas AFAIK they're fairly similar and as it happens those are the areas where you benefit from EVs the most while also being where people with highly paid jobs tend to be located.
Only 16-20% of cars on the road in the "u"s are trucks, so not really relevant anyway.
https://finance.yahoo.com/sectors/technology/articles/didn-t...
But the rules may differ for those of us who are not major automotive CEO's.
Do we really need a new car to look cosmetically different every few years to spur sales and say “new?” At the same time this means they can still customize the sheet metal, for different trims and types but the motor is the same, transmission is the same, seat is the same, etc
And for those parts, do we really need new part numbers every year? Heterogeneous is great? But something something Henry ford you can have any color as long as it’s black is also ok.
Plus it isn’t really new, brand engineering is this. Toyota grabs the bmw z4 and makes it a Supra, Mazda grabs the rav4 and makes it the cx50, etc
And personally I think most cars have been getting uglier. I would’ve been happy if they stuck with what they had 10 years ago.
So yeah, if you wanna save money, stop wasting it on a new redesign every few years. Don’t waste the money retooling to change random things every year.
They might do a cosmetic facelift every couple of years but the platform will typically stay in production for a decade or so.
GM in particular are famous for using the same chassis, drivetrain, floorpan etc on half a dozen or more models across their marques.
Still, however, as great as cheap available parts would be.. the major car brands desperately need to find ways to significantly lower the price of their cars. New cars and trucks are reaching the prices of like a big down payment you could put on a house. Standardized parts would definitely reduce costs but would that be enough? Even many 2 income households struggle to get ahead. In my opinion the number one priority of these companies should be how can they make an inexpensive car that the average person can afford.
The problem that I have with cars in general is that they use pretty old technology and you want something new that actually works OK and it does not have that much lag. While I understand the myth about manufacturers using old components because they are proven, they should get over it and use circuits made in the 21st century. Reliability has grown a lot, we don't need vacuum tubes in the cars anymore (I am being sarcastic about the vacuum tubes).
Another thing is the subtle but annoying differences in cars in different geographies: in one country you have a 360-degree camera system, but in others they don't even offer it as an add-on. For the same car. And other little things.
What I would like to see though would be to have the ability to upgrade the hardware in the car every 2-3 years. Like replace 2-3 "boxes" full of components and have "an almost new car" with improved technology.
This is a rather unenlightened take. The electronics used in cars aren't typical consumer gear - the parts are much more rugged. This is for good reason. The same car could start life parked on the side of the road in the nevada desert (wild temperature fluctuations), go on a roadtrip through death valley in the summer, and a few years later be parked on the street in florida (ridiculously humid) or somewhere in north dakota (extreme cold). Meanwhile we expect not to have any major electrical issues over a 20+ year product life. It's actually fairly absurd when you stop and think about it.
They might as well merge now and save the drama.
Hasn't this ship already sailed?
What makes you think they'd look identical? You think the only parts in a car are cosmetic parts?
The reason is because Cybersecurity is a priority for us and the Chinese are spying on us blah blah. I know for sure that cybercrime was no where as frequent as today, and with that not only is it from china anymore along with a much larger scale of intrusion and theft.
The thing is that China entered in your capitalized game and won.
Accusing any one of spying as a justification for your failures is kind of ridiculous.
The all powerful US creates sanctions, extreme protectionist and a lot of economic obstacles for everyone.
You guys are living in a dystopian world for ages. Your “free market” and free competition is an hallucination that you decided to believe.
The disasters the World had to accept in favor of the US “superiority” are far more terrible than you not being able to compete with EV.
[1]https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/exclus...
[2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SAIC-GM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZjxZ2Eh9GrA
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gung_Ho_(film)
So yes, but the drag is downstream of highly conservative product positioning not incompetence.
Even worst, if you're in California, the per mile price to charge an EV at home, without solar, is greater than filling up a hybrid Prius on today's gas prices.
Until they grow big enough to make their own glass.
For tires it does not make sense to integrate that too. Unless someone has the bright ideea to sell unconventional sizes, like 18.2" or something crazy like that.