> Correlations and cluster analyses show that high levels of secure funding for public media systems and strong structural protections for the political and economic independence of those systems are consistently and positively correlated with healthy democracies. ("Funding Democracy: Public Media and Democratic Health in 33 Countries", https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/19401612211060255)
Expanding the CBC, TVO is public media giving money to Rogers is not.
We know this will never happen in the US. The one news org in the US that tried to present real news was fully de-funded a year or 2 ago.
I literally find the news about whatever the heck is going on in the US much better in quality and detail when I get it from CBC, the BBC, France24, DW, reading Le Figaro or El Pais, etc. The CBC in particular does solid analysis of the US from an external perspective, while the contrasting american-originated coverage of the same event often seems so slanted (one way or the other) that it often barely seems to describe the same event.
You know, if only social networks didn't starve all the Canadian media for 10+ years, we would have the benefit of having some options. But here we are today, with media and journalism gutted to their simplest expression, and you pretending like "big government" is the problem in all of this.
Likewise, if an independent journalist see net income at a comparable rate to other industries and the bills are paid, in a competitive market they will lower the price of their output to compete.
There is no easy solution. The best is to leave it up to people to choose their sources.
Unfortunately, Canada is moving in wrong directions. Canadians haven't lived in EU to understand where the policies of their government (pivot to Europe and European model, if it's real) is leading to.
Not saying the government here doesn't have a problem with overspending, but it's perhaps not as bad as you might think
Canada is in a much better position that the rest of the _world_. Their net debt is only 10% of GDP. Basically only a couple oil-rich nordics do better. Anyone trying to lecture Canada on debt and finance BETTER have a very distinct pitch accent when they are doing it. If you're doing so from their southern border... stop yourself before you get started.
Canadian source on why net debt GDP ratio isn't all that https://www.fraserinstitute.org/commentary/canadas-net-debt-...
You're getting a bit stuck on terms, I think because both countries have a unit called a "dollar". But you can't compare what Canada calls a dollar to what the US calls a dollar and say that the US has a 1.4x better economy, or really anything else.
Just like public ownership of critical infrastructure, it doesn't matter what it costs, we should own it collectively.
You can't choose what doesn't exist.
Sure. The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation has been government funded for 90 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Broadcasting_Corporat...
The British Broadcasting Corporation has been government funded for a 100 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC
The Australian Broadcasting Corporation has been government funded for 94 years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_Broadcasting_Corpor...
It doesn't seem like those broadcasting corporations are wrecking their nations.
Can you demonstrate that Canada, Britain, and Australia would be better off without the CBC, the BBC, and the ABC?
Many average Canadians already pay significantly less taxes from their regular T4 salaried job (equivalent of a W2 employee), in combined federal and provincial income taxes, if you consider the healthcare costs that Americans pay on top of their W2 take-home in the private HMO run system on a monthly basis.
I've met plenty of well paid American employees of high-tech companies in the US who are paying $700 or $1000 or $1400 a month (USD currency) or more to cover themselves, their spouse, maybe one or two children and they still have a $5000 annual deductible to pay before their coverage actually kicks in.
Taxes alone. Tax freedom day in the US is April 16 on Canada June 9.
It is not comparable in methodology to the US number since it includes upstream taxes not paid directly by individuals and assumes an income significantly higher than the median. E.g. It estimates that the average family has a tax bill of $2k per year on liquor, tobacco and gambling as one egregious example. Not total spend, they think the average family is paying $2k on sin taxes (that would be $13k worth of alcohol per family, or about ten drinks per day per household at retail prices.). They have been known to include things like resource extraction levies in the personal taxes, which are levies that industry pays to the government when they extract government owned natural resources.
In other words it is thinly veiled propaganda.
If you want to know how much tax Canadians pay in comparison to Americans there are effectively infinite tax liability calculators. Until you get into the $250k brackets it is within a few points.
Half your pay in taxes? not even close. In Alberta the most you can ever pay in income taxes is 48% and you have to be above $80,000,000 in salary to achieve that.
> leave it up to people to choose their sources
Not sure how this changes that.
This isn’t Canada moving in any direction, the CBC has been around and publically funded for decades.
What are some countries where you think they're doing a good job and going in the right direction?
I swear authoritarian states will charge you far far more, and will set for you what you should consume, protecting their own interests.
I have lived in France and US, and can write long posts on this subject, given time.
All the infrastructure decaying today was built with the ample tax revenue back then, until Thatcherism, trickle down and starve the beast crap ideology corrupted everything
1. What if the government was right-wing and the news produced reflected that - would you still support it? 2. Investigative journalism was birthed in the free market era of yellow journalism, funded by consumers buying newspapers and being served ads - where is this supposed golden age of government funded media that people refer to? 3. For every Fox News, there’s a CNN/MSNBC/. For every WSJ, there’s a WaPo/NYT/LAT/etc. Aka privately funded media results in heavy left wing skew - what’s the gap that government funded media fills? 4. Government funded media is by definition propaganda - that doesn’t concern you? 5. Of the government is paying journalists’ salaries, how does that reduce conflict of interest in holding higher ups accountable more so than for journalists and privately funded outlets? Wouldn’t both be hesitant to go after their respective bosses?
We shouldn't pretend that there's no political risk, no matter if it's structured as a tax break or direct ownership: every time you tie the well-being of journalists to government policy, you inject some bias into the process.
However, journalism as such is not financially sustainable in the era of internet clickbait and AI slop, so you kinda need to subsidize reporting if you want to have any reporting at all. Otherwise, all the local news you're gonna get are gonna be Facebook gossip, fake stories engineered for clicks, and paid PR pieces.
Like, yeah, BBC minces their words when it comes to criticizing government policy, but they can also afford to send real journalists to cover real news. Do you not want that?
The New York Times and Wall Street Journal don't get any journalist specific funding from the government as far as I know, yet they're able to do investigative journalism just fine it seems.
Back when Glenn Greenwald was still there, they broke the NSA spying story thanks to Snowden, and they reported on the conspiracy in Brazil to lock up Lula on false charges. They didn't take federal funding in either the US or Brazil.
And yes, you can read all about how it works, who qualifies, what the details are, who administers the programme, and more besides. There are even 6 years of annual reports.
* https://www.canada.ca/en/canadian-heritage/services/funding/...
* https://nmc-mic.ca/lji/about-lji/how-it-works/
* https://www.canada.ca/en/canadian-heritage/services/funding/...
* https://www.canada.ca/en/revenue-agency/services/tax/busines...
The influence of American media has already been seen extensively in Canada with "maple MAGA" things like the Alberta separatism movement and referendum.
Engage with their entire point please
To act like the invisible hand will magically create the "best" news is the crudest sort of free-market fundamentalism. It ignores that news readers are not the customers of (ad-funded) media companies but the product. Marketplace success goes to those best at delivering manipulable consumers.
That's very hard to square with the key societal function of news organizations in democracies: producing skeptical, informed citizens able to thoughtfully supervise elected officials and the government.
Sure, some founders have priciples that could override these systemic pressures, but it's a lot of weight stacked against one human's willpower.
* What is news? Someone's hot takes on social media? What if a journalist quits the NY Times and starts a solo Substack publication? What if they do the same but post only on Twitter? What if a wealthy indvidual or corporation starts a news org with 10 journalists, otherwise professional, but publishes all brazen disinformation, some dangerous (e.g., dangerous health advice)? What about The Onion?
* How do you prevent government interference? You can structure the funding so its distribution is essentially automatic, such as the OP's tax break for journalist salaries. But once journalism orgs are dependent on the funding, the government can change that. In the US I wonder if the First Amendment would prohibit discrimination based on politics.
> Meta blocked news on Facebook and Instagram in Canada rather than pay under the Online News Act.
Is it a loss to receive less news via social media?
Are you just ignorant or is this you trying to make some kind of insult-joke I'm not American enough to understand?
Maybe for Canada it's ok though.
The way this works is tax cuts, which I guess is federal funding, but if a news org can build itself up with these tax cuts, it can help them jump start to a sustainable organization without needing them in the future.
They're lowering income tax on journalist salaries. They're not expanding state owned media, they're essentially lowering taxes for all journalists, making it cheaper to run independent media and reporting.
They're doing the tax cuts, but also funding and have "independent" third parties determine who is elligible.
“To avoid perceptions of conflict of interest, the government ensured that third parties adjudicate who receives local journalism initiative reporters and who is eligible for the labor tax credit,” Deegan said.
Nor is private any less captured. Fox "News" being the most obvious.
But reading the article I do think there's a good faith and right way to encourage journalism. And it could work.
For those who haven't been alive longer than social media. Local media was destroyed by large traditional media conglomerates that bought up all of the them during the golden era of traditional media. Now that they aren't profitable and are being kept alive by government how will this solve those problems?